James Pethokoukis is concerned - and rightly so - regarding a future which may not hold enough jobs if no policy action is taken. In "Why the Right resists thinking about the jobs threat from automation", Pethokoukis highlights several pertinent quotes in this regard. Erik Brynjolfsson stressed that there's no economic law which means everyone benefits from technology, even as the pie continues to grow. Data points to this possibility, as median income and GDP haven't grown in tandem with total wealth since the nineties. According to the McKinsey Global Institute, it could be that we've got about a decade to set a clearer path into motion, before the next wave of automation is adopted.
Fortunately, efforts for long term economic inclusion can begin while job numbers have greatly improved. One might liken such a process to repairing the roof while it's not raining outside, particularly since production reform never occurred during the Great Recession years. The crisis which was "too good to waste" was partly lost just the same - lost to dithering over whether recovery should take place fiscally or monetarily. Even though growth is finally occurring on monetary terms, vital services remain fiscally defined. That prevents some of the most important economic growth of all, because it is difficult for government to fund services needs without taking on more obligations for special interest wants as well.
Even though automation will produce much of what individuals need in the years ahead, it's important to make services production central to what people want. In other words, the future isn't just about reimbursing special interest wants, but making certain services product has a chance to fulfill wants for all income classes. An inclusive economy in which everyone provides for societal wants, ensures that people have enough money to pay for all those automated needs, as well.
How to think about services in a production capacity? When services mostly exist in a secondary (dependent) context, their formation is inevitably cut back when governments tighten budgets. This is why services need to be monetarily provided, through compensated and coordinated time use. Services are too important as product formation, to be given over to the vagaries of "right" neighborhoods, "right" cities, "right" family wealth formations, "right" insurance policies or "right" government deals. If there is to be reliable work and a context for meaning in the near future, services and knowledge use need to be a part of this reality.
Only stop to consider how time use matters at a personal level, to realize what is at stake. Most individuals have a strong desire to provide something unique for others. What's more, everyone needs to be able to do so on terms that do not compromise too much of one's individuality. This is what reciprocity is about - discovering the give and take that generates positive social relationships.
In an era with top down services definition and automated production, far too much reciprocity has been missing in action. It is too easy to assume that people can remain civilized through education, while allowing a fraction of the population to do the important work. But it simply doesn't work this way. For humanity to endure, all individuals need to remain an active part of working environments, and the social environments that naturally follow.
Tuesday, February 10, 2015
Monday, February 9, 2015
All Systems "Go"? The Growth Checklist
There's a lingering question, which needs better answers than has been the case thus far. "Why?" The Fed has been anxious (patient?) for quite some time, to begin normalization procedures for monetary policy "liftoff". Some aspects of their checklist appear to be in good shape, but what about the parts that are not? Maybe it's not possible to complete the checklist because...well who really knows why. Plenty of "black boxes" have been "recovered" over the years and discussed at length, whenever monetary policy "crashed and burned". Of course, economists and other onlookers have different crisis theories - possibly even different "checklists", for that matter. That's the problem - no one really knows for sure.
And complex systems can in fact fail, when certain components are left off the checklist. What about standard Fed procedures which - until the Great Recession - were taken for granted? For instance, it had become clear that a nominal target level could provide monetary stability. Why did this fact lose its importance? Atul Gawande, in "The Checklist Manifesto", wrote:
Did the earlier growth trajectory die a horrible death, or is it just temporarily missing? After all, no one explained whether it was permanently abandoned. Consequently, any present "normalization" doesn't have a good reference point, and what policy makers want is not at all clear. One gets the impression that divergence from the earlier output gap isn't "supposed" to matter. Or if divergence is discussed as though it does matter, the discussion quickly devolves into debate whether output should be regained on fiscal or monetary terms. Somehow the fact that fiscal activity follows monetary activity, is now lost in translation.
In spite of these concerns, Washington would like to keep economic circumstance essentially as they are. Thus far, policy makers seek a twentieth century repeat on slightly subdued terms, if only because there is little common vision for the twenty-first. Once production dispersed around the globe, developed nations sought growth that was based on the "more is better" approach. In other words, they raised the bar in terms of how production and consumption were "supposed" to take place. While that meant leaving some out of the game, for a long time it didn't seem to matter. Now, more participation is needed in the marketplace, even if only to help government maintain the safety net already in place...as if that were the only concern!
But how to bring back the ones who have fallen by the wayside? Demographic and related arguments for a smaller labor force participation rate, do little justice to the fact world population is still increasing, and home production hasn't been a major economic contributor for decades. New and more inclusive growth is not easy, because it means reforms which would also change the nature of supply side structure in legal and financial terms. In the meantime, "all or nothing" terms for economic inclusion appear as though tottering on the edge of inflation or deflation, depending on the way the "wind blows". Financial aspects of this "dilemma" are particularly dubious. The idea of permanent instability is reminiscent of a parent bird running ahead of the observer on the ground, pretending to have a broken wing, all the while drawing one's attention away from the nestegg.
One can only hope that when the Fed addresses normalization procedures in the future, money enough will have been printed for what is at stake. Too much "uncertainty" has been needlessly self imposed, while populations are led to believe that growth can magically materialize without the monetary backing necessary to sustain it. At the very least, public officials need to be honest about what is happening, because too much false hope continues to be spread about recovery. No one can afford to bypass low labor force participation, as though it were merely an insignificant factor of the growth checklist. Plenty of marketplace factors reflect this reality, and this is no time to pretend otherwise.
And complex systems can in fact fail, when certain components are left off the checklist. What about standard Fed procedures which - until the Great Recession - were taken for granted? For instance, it had become clear that a nominal target level could provide monetary stability. Why did this fact lose its importance? Atul Gawande, in "The Checklist Manifesto", wrote:
Faulty memory and distraction are a particular danger in what engineers call all-or-nothing processes. Whether running to the store to buy ingredients for a cake, preparing an airplane for takeoff, or evaluating a sick person in the hospital, if you miss just one key thing, you might as well not have made the effort at all.Argh. Hands off the interest rate just now, please. Gawande continues:
A further difficulty, just as insidious, is that people can lull themselves into skipping steps even when they remember them. In complex processes after all, certain steps don't always matter. ..."This has never been a problem before," people say. Until one day it is.Why is the Fed anxious to "resume altitude" at a lower trajectory? Like the proverbial rock and a hard place, the Fed appears caught between Washington's desire for normal economic circumstance, and the marketplace which senses the wishful thinking that is actually involved. As David Wessel states, "The markets don't appear to believe the Fed."
Did the earlier growth trajectory die a horrible death, or is it just temporarily missing? After all, no one explained whether it was permanently abandoned. Consequently, any present "normalization" doesn't have a good reference point, and what policy makers want is not at all clear. One gets the impression that divergence from the earlier output gap isn't "supposed" to matter. Or if divergence is discussed as though it does matter, the discussion quickly devolves into debate whether output should be regained on fiscal or monetary terms. Somehow the fact that fiscal activity follows monetary activity, is now lost in translation.
In spite of these concerns, Washington would like to keep economic circumstance essentially as they are. Thus far, policy makers seek a twentieth century repeat on slightly subdued terms, if only because there is little common vision for the twenty-first. Once production dispersed around the globe, developed nations sought growth that was based on the "more is better" approach. In other words, they raised the bar in terms of how production and consumption were "supposed" to take place. While that meant leaving some out of the game, for a long time it didn't seem to matter. Now, more participation is needed in the marketplace, even if only to help government maintain the safety net already in place...as if that were the only concern!
But how to bring back the ones who have fallen by the wayside? Demographic and related arguments for a smaller labor force participation rate, do little justice to the fact world population is still increasing, and home production hasn't been a major economic contributor for decades. New and more inclusive growth is not easy, because it means reforms which would also change the nature of supply side structure in legal and financial terms. In the meantime, "all or nothing" terms for economic inclusion appear as though tottering on the edge of inflation or deflation, depending on the way the "wind blows". Financial aspects of this "dilemma" are particularly dubious. The idea of permanent instability is reminiscent of a parent bird running ahead of the observer on the ground, pretending to have a broken wing, all the while drawing one's attention away from the nest
One can only hope that when the Fed addresses normalization procedures in the future, money enough will have been printed for what is at stake. Too much "uncertainty" has been needlessly self imposed, while populations are led to believe that growth can magically materialize without the monetary backing necessary to sustain it. At the very least, public officials need to be honest about what is happening, because too much false hope continues to be spread about recovery. No one can afford to bypass low labor force participation, as though it were merely an insignificant factor of the growth checklist. Plenty of marketplace factors reflect this reality, and this is no time to pretend otherwise.
Saturday, February 7, 2015
Time, Price and Incentive
The main problem for general (or primary) equilibrium in the present, is the lack of a marketplace for time aggregates. Presently, some of life's most important skills exist in secondary, hence partial or incomplete economic settings. Time use concerns can be difficult to measure purely in terms of standard pricing, because money needs to represent all resource value and potential - not just the choices one seeks through time use.
Resource aggregates as a whole are immense, in relation to the finite resource of time. This is why government obligations - divided up as representative of per capita responsibility - seem immense. Even though governments have vast resource capacity, many economic activities now take place at levels surpassing the time value most "mere mortals" hold.
Hence a leap of faith is involved, even given the fiscal capacity Washington holds. Any perceived risk also exists in relation to other risks. In terms of time based support, governments already have quite a few promises to keep. What's more these obligations have increased, relative to a slowdown in growth for broader resource representation. This is why further taxation has little ability to address the underlying problem of a missing marketplace in time value.
So long as an economy grows at a fast pace, it is not difficult for associations representing high skill value, to stake claims existing in relation to the broader equilibrium. But should an economy begin to slow, it can be more difficult to coordinate time use patterns at general equilibrium level. Indeed, the most important monetary functions are called into question, when governments struggle to provide the same services balancing and coordinating functions as before.
Increasingly, it is difficult for price levels to provide reliable markers for time use aggregates in services. Even the question of participation in today's services marketplace is highly politicized. Until now, the most highly valued skills sets were built on decades of preparation, and they needed to be reimbursed on those same terms - not what other economic participants could "afford".
However, those earlier stakes in time use value, left too many economic participants without reliable economic functions. Time as value in personal use, has to be sacrificed for value in personal exchange - when in fact it remains possible to do so. Furthermore, if value in exchange is either missing or insufficient, time value in use no longer retains the same productive dynamic, because it may not be possible to utilize resources other than in consumer context. Most individuals need stable and ongoing relationships with others, in order to utilize resources in any productive capacity.
Only consider that at the beginning of the twentieth century, self employment was still a reality for many individuals. Incentives tended to be internally aligned, even at the level of families which still held similar production goals in common. This was a simpler reality, in which individuals took for granted the ability to transform resources and arbitrage the resulting product. There were reasonably reliable economic gains to be had, when incentive meant getting up early in the morning to undertake activity for economic and personal gain.
Once product became more associated with institutional production, time balance gradually shifted away from both individual and family efforts, as incentives were externalized. With a little luck and a reliable work role, "early risers" continued to benefit from personal effort. However, without a career or ownership stake in a production base, incentive could still gradually be lost.
As the twentieth century progressed, the odds became greater for success in terms of paid employment, rather than production on personal terms. Even though that meant externally aligned incentives (if one didn't "own" some crucial aspect of the job, a day could feel "long"), the tradeoff could mean not worrying about money to pay the bills. Once again, the pendulum is swinging towards a need for internal alignment - even while business formation slows and older firms dominate the national stage. Where to begin?
A marketplace for time use would realign incentive, but many aspects of life would be unrecognizable from a century earlier. To be sure, locals would still coordinate for commonly shared goal sets and activities, just as they once coordinated for agricultural and simpler production activities. The main difference is that services would become the first focus of time alignment, and further production would follow. Using services as a central organizational factor, would allow individuals to rediscover production on the changing terms of automation and 3D printing as well.
By realigning time use within locally acquired resource context, more individuals would have a chance to learn services and production on new terms. Fortunately, individual groups are capable of balancing and coordinating functions which governments should not have to be entirely responsible for. Not everyone needs high pay as the primary incentive for high skill work. How many would choose environments which support high skill levels on simpler terms? It would be interesting indeed, to find out.
Resource aggregates as a whole are immense, in relation to the finite resource of time. This is why government obligations - divided up as representative of per capita responsibility - seem immense. Even though governments have vast resource capacity, many economic activities now take place at levels surpassing the time value most "mere mortals" hold.
Hence a leap of faith is involved, even given the fiscal capacity Washington holds. Any perceived risk also exists in relation to other risks. In terms of time based support, governments already have quite a few promises to keep. What's more these obligations have increased, relative to a slowdown in growth for broader resource representation. This is why further taxation has little ability to address the underlying problem of a missing marketplace in time value.
So long as an economy grows at a fast pace, it is not difficult for associations representing high skill value, to stake claims existing in relation to the broader equilibrium. But should an economy begin to slow, it can be more difficult to coordinate time use patterns at general equilibrium level. Indeed, the most important monetary functions are called into question, when governments struggle to provide the same services balancing and coordinating functions as before.
Increasingly, it is difficult for price levels to provide reliable markers for time use aggregates in services. Even the question of participation in today's services marketplace is highly politicized. Until now, the most highly valued skills sets were built on decades of preparation, and they needed to be reimbursed on those same terms - not what other economic participants could "afford".
However, those earlier stakes in time use value, left too many economic participants without reliable economic functions. Time as value in personal use, has to be sacrificed for value in personal exchange - when in fact it remains possible to do so. Furthermore, if value in exchange is either missing or insufficient, time value in use no longer retains the same productive dynamic, because it may not be possible to utilize resources other than in consumer context. Most individuals need stable and ongoing relationships with others, in order to utilize resources in any productive capacity.
Only consider that at the beginning of the twentieth century, self employment was still a reality for many individuals. Incentives tended to be internally aligned, even at the level of families which still held similar production goals in common. This was a simpler reality, in which individuals took for granted the ability to transform resources and arbitrage the resulting product. There were reasonably reliable economic gains to be had, when incentive meant getting up early in the morning to undertake activity for economic and personal gain.
Once product became more associated with institutional production, time balance gradually shifted away from both individual and family efforts, as incentives were externalized. With a little luck and a reliable work role, "early risers" continued to benefit from personal effort. However, without a career or ownership stake in a production base, incentive could still gradually be lost.
As the twentieth century progressed, the odds became greater for success in terms of paid employment, rather than production on personal terms. Even though that meant externally aligned incentives (if one didn't "own" some crucial aspect of the job, a day could feel "long"), the tradeoff could mean not worrying about money to pay the bills. Once again, the pendulum is swinging towards a need for internal alignment - even while business formation slows and older firms dominate the national stage. Where to begin?
A marketplace for time use would realign incentive, but many aspects of life would be unrecognizable from a century earlier. To be sure, locals would still coordinate for commonly shared goal sets and activities, just as they once coordinated for agricultural and simpler production activities. The main difference is that services would become the first focus of time alignment, and further production would follow. Using services as a central organizational factor, would allow individuals to rediscover production on the changing terms of automation and 3D printing as well.
By realigning time use within locally acquired resource context, more individuals would have a chance to learn services and production on new terms. Fortunately, individual groups are capable of balancing and coordinating functions which governments should not have to be entirely responsible for. Not everyone needs high pay as the primary incentive for high skill work. How many would choose environments which support high skill levels on simpler terms? It would be interesting indeed, to find out.
Thursday, February 5, 2015
Knowledge Mobility is Important for Social Mobility
In order for social mobility to remain viable, knowledge use dispersal beyond today's prosperous regions is a big part of the equation. But why is this the case? Applied knowledge in action, is today's primary resource use pattern. One could visualize knowledge use as the soil of a garden, by which every product imaginable could (potentially) grow.
For a long time, land use starred in the primary role of resource generation. In recent centuries, the factory floor shared a starring role as well, before product could be generated with less labor. Ample choice in land use and tradable goods production, increased growth and social mobility - so long as labor and skills sets remained interchangeable options.
Divisions of labor in traditional production were created in part so that interchangeability remained possible. These flexible time use options were a major contributing component to productivity. Hence divisions of labor in factory work are different in nature, from arbitrarily fixed and less productive divisions in some knowledge use capacity. Indeed, breaking free of the high skill requirements of earlier guilds, meant more choices for populations as a whole. Increased time use specialization in a singular capacity - then as now - was capable of stalling mobility patterns and economic growth in general.
If knowledge could also be utilized as interchangeable components in the present, productivity gains would mean that lower income levels would have access to important services formation otherwise not be possible. Greater services output would be generated. Since individuals would rely on skills portfolios instead of single skill sets, less risk would be involved for the costs of moving to locations where knowledge use systems exist.
As knowledge use increasingly separated between high and low skill sets, living quarters mirrored this change as various income levels have become more geographically dispersed. Segregation in work and living environments has been the result, making it more difficult for many forms of enterprise to remain in close proximity to one another. Even the factor of wide income variation, contributes to decreased mobility.
At the same time nations are also limiting mobility across national boundaries. A major reason for government reluctance to accept immigrants, is that existing services marketplace capacity is already being stretched for local citizens. Which is more problematic: the income divide, or the growing difficulty of moving beyond one's personal economic circumstance? Carola Binder's response to an article from Gregory Clark suggests that while some measure of equality is desirable; so too, is mobility. Here's Clark:
What's more, patent thickets have considerably slowed down economic growth in real terms. There's an odd sort of knowledge use standoff in all this. In a recent post, James Pethokoukis writes, "If government doesn't do basic science, don't expect business to." Even though monetary activity has recently increased relative to fiscal activity, this hasn't translated into research gains. In a recent paper, Packalen and Bhattacharya note that innovation in major cities has slowed, which is surprising since prosperous regions are the main "idea centers" of the present.
In an era when knowledge use reigns supreme, the high skill meritocracy could be considered the new nobility. However it is not easy to add further taxation to high incomes, in an attempt to address wealth disparities. Not enough redistribution would result, for lower income levels to gain needed services from today's current providers. Equally important is the fact that knowledge wealth for the elite does not come easy. Not only are the costs of economic access quite high, these professions involve a high level of lifetime commitment.
A better approach to maintain social mobility and growth potential is to make knowledge use possible through more flexible means. Knowledge use which relies on time coordination instead of merit, would mean that individuals have a choice for production and consumption of primary services, when it is not possible to access existing services networks.
There is nothing wrong with the human desire for meritocracy, for it is capable of delivering tremendous rewards. Who - given the chance - doesn't want the best surgery that "money can buy"? Except it is not always possible - or realistic - for all of society to expect a form of service delivery that requires decades of education and debt loads. The main drawback to meritocratic knowledge use as the only service option, is that others need to have similar merit in knowledge use capacity to approach time coordination on the same terms.
It is possible to gain benefits from coordinated time use at multiple levels. Some knowledge use systems would gradually prove capable of generating research which rivals institutions that approach education in linear context. Eventually, new systems would mean being able to work with the resources in one's own environment, even in the most rural of settings.
Equal time use is certainly not for everyone. Coordination for services through monetary means will always be easier. The only problem is that services through price coordination alone means a permanently limited market, because of its secondary nature to primary wealth. Time arbitrage turns services into primary wealth, and in so doing opens up a marketplace which otherwise isn't possible. What's more, time arbitrage may be the best means to maintain balance in knowledge use and resource capacity for populations in general. Perhaps that's the best rationale, of all.
For a long time, land use starred in the primary role of resource generation. In recent centuries, the factory floor shared a starring role as well, before product could be generated with less labor. Ample choice in land use and tradable goods production, increased growth and social mobility - so long as labor and skills sets remained interchangeable options.
Divisions of labor in traditional production were created in part so that interchangeability remained possible. These flexible time use options were a major contributing component to productivity. Hence divisions of labor in factory work are different in nature, from arbitrarily fixed and less productive divisions in some knowledge use capacity. Indeed, breaking free of the high skill requirements of earlier guilds, meant more choices for populations as a whole. Increased time use specialization in a singular capacity - then as now - was capable of stalling mobility patterns and economic growth in general.
If knowledge could also be utilized as interchangeable components in the present, productivity gains would mean that lower income levels would have access to important services formation otherwise not be possible. Greater services output would be generated. Since individuals would rely on skills portfolios instead of single skill sets, less risk would be involved for the costs of moving to locations where knowledge use systems exist.
As knowledge use increasingly separated between high and low skill sets, living quarters mirrored this change as various income levels have become more geographically dispersed. Segregation in work and living environments has been the result, making it more difficult for many forms of enterprise to remain in close proximity to one another. Even the factor of wide income variation, contributes to decreased mobility.
At the same time nations are also limiting mobility across national boundaries. A major reason for government reluctance to accept immigrants, is that existing services marketplace capacity is already being stretched for local citizens. Which is more problematic: the income divide, or the growing difficulty of moving beyond one's personal economic circumstance? Carola Binder's response to an article from Gregory Clark suggests that while some measure of equality is desirable; so too, is mobility. Here's Clark:
We cannot change the winners in the social lottery, but we can change the value of their prizes.But how does one think about this? How can knowledge use become a more substantial component of the marketplace, without affecting the integrity of today's limited high skills services environment? For one thing, there needs to be a better understanding of the knowledge sets which specifically belong to present day institutions, and the vast array of earlier knowledge gains which remain open for new knowledge use systems to build from. Even though much is under patent, it's too easy to forget the vast amount that could be tapped into by anyone.
What's more, patent thickets have considerably slowed down economic growth in real terms. There's an odd sort of knowledge use standoff in all this. In a recent post, James Pethokoukis writes, "If government doesn't do basic science, don't expect business to." Even though monetary activity has recently increased relative to fiscal activity, this hasn't translated into research gains. In a recent paper, Packalen and Bhattacharya note that innovation in major cities has slowed, which is surprising since prosperous regions are the main "idea centers" of the present.
In an era when knowledge use reigns supreme, the high skill meritocracy could be considered the new nobility. However it is not easy to add further taxation to high incomes, in an attempt to address wealth disparities. Not enough redistribution would result, for lower income levels to gain needed services from today's current providers. Equally important is the fact that knowledge wealth for the elite does not come easy. Not only are the costs of economic access quite high, these professions involve a high level of lifetime commitment.
A better approach to maintain social mobility and growth potential is to make knowledge use possible through more flexible means. Knowledge use which relies on time coordination instead of merit, would mean that individuals have a choice for production and consumption of primary services, when it is not possible to access existing services networks.
There is nothing wrong with the human desire for meritocracy, for it is capable of delivering tremendous rewards. Who - given the chance - doesn't want the best surgery that "money can buy"? Except it is not always possible - or realistic - for all of society to expect a form of service delivery that requires decades of education and debt loads. The main drawback to meritocratic knowledge use as the only service option, is that others need to have similar merit in knowledge use capacity to approach time coordination on the same terms.
It is possible to gain benefits from coordinated time use at multiple levels. Some knowledge use systems would gradually prove capable of generating research which rivals institutions that approach education in linear context. Eventually, new systems would mean being able to work with the resources in one's own environment, even in the most rural of settings.
Equal time use is certainly not for everyone. Coordination for services through monetary means will always be easier. The only problem is that services through price coordination alone means a permanently limited market, because of its secondary nature to primary wealth. Time arbitrage turns services into primary wealth, and in so doing opens up a marketplace which otherwise isn't possible. What's more, time arbitrage may be the best means to maintain balance in knowledge use and resource capacity for populations in general. Perhaps that's the best rationale, of all.
Wednesday, February 4, 2015
Who are the Marginalized?
As alluded to in my last post, this is one of those moments when the main thing standing in my way is a lack of time for the competing posts in my head! However, I have often considered this question over the years, and a recent article from Catherine Rampell encouraged me to place it in a broader context. Of all the marginalized, the fate of older millennials is one of today's most pressing concerns. From Catherine Rampell:
Once, my brother asked who - exactly - was I writing for. What does it even mean, to assume that I'm ultimately writing for the marginalized? Not only do these individuals come from all walks of life, many scarcely realize it when they are negotiating from a compromised position. Fortunately, much of life uncertainty is often relative and temporary.
Even so, a lack of realization re one's position can be problematic in itself, for a person may not understand what is happening for a long time. Normally one "falls"...then bounces back! Hence marginalization occurs in any number of stages, and from any number of causes. Individuals may not be aware of a growing presence of contributing factors, until little power remains to negotiate for one's needs - either in the marketplace or at a personal level. Baby boomers - for instance - might not realize they are falling behind peers, friends and extended family until it is quite late in the game, and a questionable "retirement" looms in the near distance.
While hiring has greatly improved of late, much about the workplace has dramatically changed from a decade earlier. When labor force participation is low, many who once would have been hired in spite of a few drawbacks, are now passed over for those with a better credit report or fewer health concerns, for instance. This means more problems for those with below average grades; a lack of confidence, physical stamina or general resources; living in the wrong area, the list goes on and on. One need not be "below average" in some respect, to miss out on job opportunities. According to Jim Clifton, chairman and CEO of Gallup, in "The Big Lie: 5.6% unemployment":
How could all these groups do a better job of reaching out - not only to those in need of help, but to one another as well? To be sure, there are networks which exist for them to do so, but they are not easy for anyone "outside the loop" so to speak, to discover. Some of these networks exist in the applied settings of prosperous cities and regions, whereas others exist in the more theoretical context of higher education. How much do they communicate their efforts with one another, and with the public as a whole?
For one thing, even though people want to help, there isn't really a common vision for reintegrating the marginalized back into society. One would think a digitized age could make all this easier, but in a sense that is part of the problem. There are so many ongoing dialogues which are intent on solving problems, but so far everyone is mostly speaking in different languages.
Indeed, conversations and approaches are so different, it can be difficult to remember the same concerns are being expressed time and again. Thus the task at hand is to to connect pathways, so that common visions can become possible. More paths need to cross, and more cross pollination needs to happen. It's not just a matter of making sure the marginalized don't fall through the cracks, but making certain these individuals play their own roles in moving society forward. After all, this group comprises the missing marketplace, the missing growth, and the missing hope for the future.
Update: A related report - http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/02/household-formation-within-the-boomerang-generation.html#.VNKMqdX3-iw
Young people are finally leaving the nest. Move up an age bracket, though, and the trends are heading in the wrong direction. Americans age 25 to 34 seem to be regressing...Yale's Lisa Kahn finds that people who graduate from college during a time of high unemployment earn significantly lower wages than workers with better timing. This differential persists not for a year or two but for decades. Why such long lasting scars? When openings are rare, young people take whatever job is available and get stuck on a lower trajectory...There's been a lot of pain for market monetarists, in knowing the setback these young workers experienced should not have been so severe. Had the Fed maintained a nominal spending path at the outset of what became the Great Recession, the entire life trajectory of older millennials would be taking place at a more dynamic level. And yet, this is only the latest group with real disadvantages in the marketplace. It continues to suffer along with other groups, as extremely low inflation means populations as a whole aren't keeping up with marketplace gains.
Once, my brother asked who - exactly - was I writing for. What does it even mean, to assume that I'm ultimately writing for the marginalized? Not only do these individuals come from all walks of life, many scarcely realize it when they are negotiating from a compromised position. Fortunately, much of life uncertainty is often relative and temporary.
Even so, a lack of realization re one's position can be problematic in itself, for a person may not understand what is happening for a long time. Normally one "falls"...then bounces back! Hence marginalization occurs in any number of stages, and from any number of causes. Individuals may not be aware of a growing presence of contributing factors, until little power remains to negotiate for one's needs - either in the marketplace or at a personal level. Baby boomers - for instance - might not realize they are falling behind peers, friends and extended family until it is quite late in the game, and a questionable "retirement" looms in the near distance.
While hiring has greatly improved of late, much about the workplace has dramatically changed from a decade earlier. When labor force participation is low, many who once would have been hired in spite of a few drawbacks, are now passed over for those with a better credit report or fewer health concerns, for instance. This means more problems for those with below average grades; a lack of confidence, physical stamina or general resources; living in the wrong area, the list goes on and on. One need not be "below average" in some respect, to miss out on job opportunities. According to Jim Clifton, chairman and CEO of Gallup, in "The Big Lie: 5.6% unemployment":
Right now, as many as 30 million Americans are either out of work or severely underemployed. Trust me, the vast majority of them aren't throwing parties to toast "falling" unemployment".Since the Great Recession, individuals and groups have tried to reach out to the marginalized in multiple capacities. That doesn't even count the organizations and government programs, which have been tending to many among the marginalized all along.
How could all these groups do a better job of reaching out - not only to those in need of help, but to one another as well? To be sure, there are networks which exist for them to do so, but they are not easy for anyone "outside the loop" so to speak, to discover. Some of these networks exist in the applied settings of prosperous cities and regions, whereas others exist in the more theoretical context of higher education. How much do they communicate their efforts with one another, and with the public as a whole?
For one thing, even though people want to help, there isn't really a common vision for reintegrating the marginalized back into society. One would think a digitized age could make all this easier, but in a sense that is part of the problem. There are so many ongoing dialogues which are intent on solving problems, but so far everyone is mostly speaking in different languages.
Indeed, conversations and approaches are so different, it can be difficult to remember the same concerns are being expressed time and again. Thus the task at hand is to to connect pathways, so that common visions can become possible. More paths need to cross, and more cross pollination needs to happen. It's not just a matter of making sure the marginalized don't fall through the cracks, but making certain these individuals play their own roles in moving society forward. After all, this group comprises the missing marketplace, the missing growth, and the missing hope for the future.
Update: A related report - http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2015/02/household-formation-within-the-boomerang-generation.html#.VNKMqdX3-iw
Midweek Market Monetarist Links and Summaries - 2/4/15
"Is it just the recession? We are now seeing unemployment falling sharply, but growth seems to be declining even further, to just .31% in the last 12 months, far below the growth rates that America has seen for many generations." (Scott Sumner) Investment flows and population growth
The Great Recession wasn't even approached on monetarist terms: The Great Recession happened because we ignored Friedman's ideas
If inflation were to rise in the next recession (countercyclical), the recommendation from Calomiris could be appropriate. Calomiris on Fed policy
Next recession? Still bumping bottom...The New Normal (Bill Woolsey wins!)
"The real question is how many curves." Is the Fed behind the curve?
Lots of people still want to hold Swiss francs...The issue SNB defenders don't address
More of the new economic territory...Japan continues to add jobs at an astounding rate, as unemployment falls to the lowest level in decades
It will be interesting to see how this plays out: The NGDP moment
Scott looks at the possibilities: Where would an aggregate labor comp target fail?
Scott at Econlog:
Questions for Keynesians (show me the data)
The CBO's forecast, with and without austerity
The Achilles heel of the right A few thoughts on Greece
Policymakers don't want to unleash the "beast" (Marcus Nunes) https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/28/why-do-many-most-economists-despise-hate-money-and-monetary-policy/
Why bother meeting every six weeks? https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/28/they-are-grossly-overpaid/
When fiscal policy provides an "excuse" https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/29/the-inflation-target-trap-the-case-of-israel/
"Overheat" is possibly the most unfortunate word of all: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/30/calomiris-to-fomc-dont-hesitate-get-em-up-and-fast/
Willingly blind to the data: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/31/confident-loonies-at-the-fomc/
Will the replacement be better? https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/31/plosser-the-perjurer/
First, repair the growth trajectory...https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/debating-the-wrong-rule/
Needed - a change in the monetary regime: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/untrue-truths/
Apparently, someone replied "yes" too many times to "All systems go?", when the real answer was "no". https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/03/time-for-liftoff-why/
A fifty-fifty chance of deflation in 2015? (Evan Soltas) http://esoltas.blogspot.com/2015/01/the-deflation-coin-flip.html
How do AS and AD really factor into the macro data? (Britmouse) https://uneconomical.wordpress.com/2015/01/29/uk-supply-side-counterfactual-updated/
Friedman: take the good parts and - alas - leave the rest (Bonnie Carr) https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/01/29/freidmans-mixed-bag-blame-or-blameless/
If NGDP falls, so too does the value of their debt...https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/02/03/ngdp-goes-big-time-with-greece-proposal/
Encouraging, thus far (Lars Christensen) http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/01/31/draghis-golden-oppurtunity-building-the-perfect-firewall/
Lars has been busy with presentations and interviews: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/01/re-visiting-iceland-options-for-monetary-and-currency-reform-in-iceland/
NGDP as a benchmark: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/02/how-to-choose-a-good-monetary-regime/
Varoufakis' proposal works as a general principle for debt restructuring: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/03/jens-weidmann-should-be-promoting-some-of-varoufakis-ideas/
How illiquid is illiquid...really? (Nick Rowe) http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/01/why-shouldnt-central-banks-buy-risky-and-illiquid-assets.html
One person's risk is another's haven: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/what-is-the-right-sort-of-risky-asset-for-central-banks-to-own.html
A good example from Nick: "If I want to shrink the total market value of my autographs I must threaten to print more autographs." http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/if-a-central-bank-wants-to-shrink-it-must-threaten-to-grow-autographed-edition.html
If only a Fed audit would be worthwhile! But is that too much, to ask? (Bill Woolsey) Audit the Fed!
Bonnie Carr responds: https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/woolsey-audit-the-fed/
Bill Sums up some recent online discussions: SNB and Swiss Francs
Does Plosser still believe deflation is desirable? (Benjamin Cole) https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/the-sad-nyt-exit-interview-of-charles-plosser-fomc-board-member-fed-philly-president/
Thus far, the seventies are still framed in the wrong economic context: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/03/charles-plossers-other-big-historical-revisions/
Among other things, "Monetary policy wasn't loose in the 2000s." (Kevin Erdmann) http://idiosyncraticwhisk.blogspot.com/2015/02/a-brief-rant-on-monetary-policy.html
Unfortunately, the Fed and Mr. Dudley are holding what are basically consensus positions: http://idiosyncraticwhisk.blogspot.com/2015/02/we-are-100.html
How much can Greece accomplish? (Greg Ip) http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2015/02/03/for-greece-gdp-linked-debt-may-be-more-curiousity-than-cure/?mod=WSJBlog
The Great Recession wasn't even approached on monetarist terms: The Great Recession happened because we ignored Friedman's ideas
If inflation were to rise in the next recession (countercyclical), the recommendation from Calomiris could be appropriate. Calomiris on Fed policy
Next recession? Still bumping bottom...The New Normal (Bill Woolsey wins!)
"The real question is how many curves." Is the Fed behind the curve?
Lots of people still want to hold Swiss francs...The issue SNB defenders don't address
More of the new economic territory...Japan continues to add jobs at an astounding rate, as unemployment falls to the lowest level in decades
It will be interesting to see how this plays out: The NGDP moment
Scott looks at the possibilities: Where would an aggregate labor comp target fail?
Scott at Econlog:
Questions for Keynesians (show me the data)
The CBO's forecast, with and without austerity
The Achilles heel of the right A few thoughts on Greece
Policymakers don't want to unleash the "beast" (Marcus Nunes) https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/28/why-do-many-most-economists-despise-hate-money-and-monetary-policy/
Why bother meeting every six weeks? https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/28/they-are-grossly-overpaid/
When fiscal policy provides an "excuse" https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/29/the-inflation-target-trap-the-case-of-israel/
"Overheat" is possibly the most unfortunate word of all: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/30/calomiris-to-fomc-dont-hesitate-get-em-up-and-fast/
Willingly blind to the data: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/31/confident-loonies-at-the-fomc/
Will the replacement be better? https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/01/31/plosser-the-perjurer/
First, repair the growth trajectory...https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/debating-the-wrong-rule/
Needed - a change in the monetary regime: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/untrue-truths/
Apparently, someone replied "yes" too many times to "All systems go?", when the real answer was "no". https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/03/time-for-liftoff-why/
A fifty-fifty chance of deflation in 2015? (Evan Soltas) http://esoltas.blogspot.com/2015/01/the-deflation-coin-flip.html
How do AS and AD really factor into the macro data? (Britmouse) https://uneconomical.wordpress.com/2015/01/29/uk-supply-side-counterfactual-updated/
Friedman: take the good parts and - alas - leave the rest (Bonnie Carr) https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/01/29/freidmans-mixed-bag-blame-or-blameless/
If NGDP falls, so too does the value of their debt...https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/02/03/ngdp-goes-big-time-with-greece-proposal/
Encouraging, thus far (Lars Christensen) http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/01/31/draghis-golden-oppurtunity-building-the-perfect-firewall/
Lars has been busy with presentations and interviews: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/01/re-visiting-iceland-options-for-monetary-and-currency-reform-in-iceland/
NGDP as a benchmark: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/02/how-to-choose-a-good-monetary-regime/
Varoufakis' proposal works as a general principle for debt restructuring: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/03/jens-weidmann-should-be-promoting-some-of-varoufakis-ideas/
How illiquid is illiquid...really? (Nick Rowe) http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/01/why-shouldnt-central-banks-buy-risky-and-illiquid-assets.html
One person's risk is another's haven: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/what-is-the-right-sort-of-risky-asset-for-central-banks-to-own.html
A good example from Nick: "If I want to shrink the total market value of my autographs I must threaten to print more autographs." http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/if-a-central-bank-wants-to-shrink-it-must-threaten-to-grow-autographed-edition.html
If only a Fed audit would be worthwhile! But is that too much, to ask? (Bill Woolsey) Audit the Fed!
Bonnie Carr responds: https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/woolsey-audit-the-fed/
Bill Sums up some recent online discussions: SNB and Swiss Francs
Does Plosser still believe deflation is desirable? (Benjamin Cole) https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/the-sad-nyt-exit-interview-of-charles-plosser-fomc-board-member-fed-philly-president/
Thus far, the seventies are still framed in the wrong economic context: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/03/charles-plossers-other-big-historical-revisions/
Among other things, "Monetary policy wasn't loose in the 2000s." (Kevin Erdmann) http://idiosyncraticwhisk.blogspot.com/2015/02/a-brief-rant-on-monetary-policy.html
Unfortunately, the Fed and Mr. Dudley are holding what are basically consensus positions: http://idiosyncraticwhisk.blogspot.com/2015/02/we-are-100.html
How much can Greece accomplish? (Greg Ip) http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2015/02/03/for-greece-gdp-linked-debt-may-be-more-curiousity-than-cure/?mod=WSJBlog
Tuesday, February 3, 2015
Why is Housing Such a Lousy Investment?
There's a couple of issues I want to address right now, but it just seems like a good day to deal with this one head on. Increasingly, people a lot younger than myself are beginning to question the rationale for today's housing structures, in investment based terms.
"Big houses" for (practically) everyone were essentially a twentieth century product, in the U.S. In the post war years, changes in finance and housing formation, vastly contributed to government growth. For the most part, these changes remained reasonable, so long as incomes could readily be associated with jobs in many regions in the country. However, as people increasingly need to rely on their own wits for finding gainful employment, they are forced to look anew at the way primary investments actually take place.
Okay, I'm already getting "wordy" in this post, hence will cut to the chase. Housing is a lousy investment, because it does not provide the productive income people often need, when they do not have sufficient work options. Yes, housing investment means one does not have to pay rent, and one can even live rent free if a house is owned outright. Great...right? Not if property taxes are coming due, food still needs to be put on the table, and there is no nearby work.
As a result: if finding employment is difficult in a given area, and people don't have ready means to arbitrage their time, they need to arbitrage home value, somehow. No, not for purposes of yet another ridiculous loan, but for income. Unfortunately, they are discouraged in this effort at the level of family, legal structures and municipal structures. How so?
Family may not want another family member living in the family home, to take on a roommate who could provide income. Or, in a divorce settlement a judge may rule that the person remaining in a house cannot gain income from said roommate possibility, should one's spouse move away and leave the remaining partner in a bind. Last but certainly not least, the city may not appreciate the fact that musicians would like to utilize a couple of rooms in their home as a recording studio. In spite of what people imagine about the lack of zoning in Houston, I encountered this situation in the seventies, and discovered most newer housing in Houston prohibited these kinds of business options.
It's easy to imagine that individuals are "sitting pretty" if they live in a house that is paid off. Not so fast. Whether the house was paid for in cash or a thirty year commitment was involved, that house still isn't generating an income stream. This is particularly an issue, if someone's education or ability also isn't generating an income stream in a given area. True, the lack of housing income stream may not be problematic if a person has retirement income or lives where nearby jobs are available. But what if these options aren't present? That essentially means someone needs to move where the jobs are.
Sell the house, so as to have a cushion for moving expenses and what may be a long job search? Not so fast. Chances are the house is owned by more than one family member (in some states, even if divorced from that family member) and the house cannot be sold. So the last remaining person (of an earlier existing household) who moves away from a collectively owned home, forfeits his or her rights to the house, and yet that is the only way to personal freedom. Not every person is healthy enough or strong enough to give up those house rights. The remaining option? Everyone waits for someone to die, so the house can finally get some TLC by someone who is free to personally take care of the deteriorating structure, without loss of resources to other family members.
Many baby boomers don't relate to house investments quite the way I do, which is probably a darn good thing. These are difficult aspects of life which really deserve to remain hidden, were it not for the problems they now impose on societies in general. Some know all too well the issues at stake. Yet there is almost no gain from speaking up, and in many instances it means further social isolation, to do so. Sometimes people simply react to these impossible circumstance and end up in prison. Fortunately, those younger than myself are starting to figure these things out and with a little luck, changes will be on the way. It is particularly insane to expect someone to hold a thirty year investment which does not support them back in any tangible way other than a place to lay one's head. If anyone ever wondered why I use the term flexible building components waaaaay too often, now they know why.
I would personally like to see local investment options which - after a ten year ongoing commitment - actually provide a time cushion for anyone who needs to engage in productive activity which is not presently compensated on its own merits. Just think if these local investment programs were begun at an early age, to provide savings for children who are monetarily compensated for assisting peers in ongoing educational activities. One could experience their first moments of investment provided freedom, just as they are entering their adulthood years. Hopefully, better investment opportunities will become a part of the near future.
"Big houses" for (practically) everyone were essentially a twentieth century product, in the U.S. In the post war years, changes in finance and housing formation, vastly contributed to government growth. For the most part, these changes remained reasonable, so long as incomes could readily be associated with jobs in many regions in the country. However, as people increasingly need to rely on their own wits for finding gainful employment, they are forced to look anew at the way primary investments actually take place.
Okay, I'm already getting "wordy" in this post, hence will cut to the chase. Housing is a lousy investment, because it does not provide the productive income people often need, when they do not have sufficient work options. Yes, housing investment means one does not have to pay rent, and one can even live rent free if a house is owned outright. Great...right? Not if property taxes are coming due, food still needs to be put on the table, and there is no nearby work.
As a result: if finding employment is difficult in a given area, and people don't have ready means to arbitrage their time, they need to arbitrage home value, somehow. No, not for purposes of yet another ridiculous loan, but for income. Unfortunately, they are discouraged in this effort at the level of family, legal structures and municipal structures. How so?
Family may not want another family member living in the family home, to take on a roommate who could provide income. Or, in a divorce settlement a judge may rule that the person remaining in a house cannot gain income from said roommate possibility, should one's spouse move away and leave the remaining partner in a bind. Last but certainly not least, the city may not appreciate the fact that musicians would like to utilize a couple of rooms in their home as a recording studio. In spite of what people imagine about the lack of zoning in Houston, I encountered this situation in the seventies, and discovered most newer housing in Houston prohibited these kinds of business options.
It's easy to imagine that individuals are "sitting pretty" if they live in a house that is paid off. Not so fast. Whether the house was paid for in cash or a thirty year commitment was involved, that house still isn't generating an income stream. This is particularly an issue, if someone's education or ability also isn't generating an income stream in a given area. True, the lack of housing income stream may not be problematic if a person has retirement income or lives where nearby jobs are available. But what if these options aren't present? That essentially means someone needs to move where the jobs are.
Sell the house, so as to have a cushion for moving expenses and what may be a long job search? Not so fast. Chances are the house is owned by more than one family member (in some states, even if divorced from that family member) and the house cannot be sold. So the last remaining person (of an earlier existing household) who moves away from a collectively owned home, forfeits his or her rights to the house, and yet that is the only way to personal freedom. Not every person is healthy enough or strong enough to give up those house rights. The remaining option? Everyone waits for someone to die, so the house can finally get some TLC by someone who is free to personally take care of the deteriorating structure, without loss of resources to other family members.
Many baby boomers don't relate to house investments quite the way I do, which is probably a darn good thing. These are difficult aspects of life which really deserve to remain hidden, were it not for the problems they now impose on societies in general. Some know all too well the issues at stake. Yet there is almost no gain from speaking up, and in many instances it means further social isolation, to do so. Sometimes people simply react to these impossible circumstance and end up in prison. Fortunately, those younger than myself are starting to figure these things out and with a little luck, changes will be on the way. It is particularly insane to expect someone to hold a thirty year investment which does not support them back in any tangible way other than a place to lay one's head. If anyone ever wondered why I use the term flexible building components waaaaay too often, now they know why.
I would personally like to see local investment options which - after a ten year ongoing commitment - actually provide a time cushion for anyone who needs to engage in productive activity which is not presently compensated on its own merits. Just think if these local investment programs were begun at an early age, to provide savings for children who are monetarily compensated for assisting peers in ongoing educational activities. One could experience their first moments of investment provided freedom, just as they are entering their adulthood years. Hopefully, better investment opportunities will become a part of the near future.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)