Wednesday, March 18, 2015

How Much Austerity is Illusory?

Before any nation succumbs to "future necessary" austerity, fiscal restraint gloom and economic slowdowns in general, it helps to remember that meaningful action now could still change everything. But first, consider where change might begin. Where money is spent by governments, how helpful is that spending in general? How much does political compromise or hidden tax strategies blunt the effect? How much is simply lost in translation to entities which already had the power and ability to take care of themselves? Inevitably, these groups stand between governments and those who could have put redistribution to reasonably good use. The process isn't just inefficient, it is often counterproductive. So why bother at all?

In a perfect world - should fiscal spending still be deemed necessary after the hard questions are confronted - what can these forms of management and organization contribute, which may be difficult or "impossible" to procure from other vantage points? If said activity is difficult to imagine elsewhere...why, exactly? Granted, if justice is at stake, public management may be better able to represent the whole. But are other determining factors of wealth provision - such as healthcare or building codes - culturally "written in stone"?

Of course, fiscal policy will remain a major component of economic activity - in spite of protestations to the contrary or the limited marketplace results of the present. However, the fact that fiscal spending has entered a period of relative retrenchment - partly the result of a supply side which is damaged from too many government favors - cannot be ignored. And without production reform, privatization of services in their present incarnation, would prove a huge mistake. In all of this, governments are losing their ability to provide the kinds of safety nets that populations need most - particularly in the U.S. It's not so much about where or how the money gets spent, but what is ultimately accomplished.

Austerity would not have to be an inevitable reality for any government, if debts and obligations were better understood by everyone, and provided for at the outset. Today's future austerity threats are a result of accounting obfuscations and the default gridlock which Washington now experiences. Even though monetary policy has proven capable of offsetting fiscal losses, the limited nature of both services and housing provisions continue to distort growth potential. Services growth in particular remains stymied by political opposition, where determination on each side effectively means that no one "gets their way".

It would be better to begin anew, with services that are capable of sidestepping both governmental redistribution patterns and the hard consumption definitions dictated by special interests in these circumstance - particularly for lower income levels.  As noted by Korpi and Palme in "The Paradox of Redistribution", "The greater the degree of low income targeting, the smaller the redistribution budget." Eduardo Porter, in "Patching up the Social Safety Net", says:
Unsurprisingly, the United States government provides one of the most threadbare social insurance nets among advanced nations The question is, as we age and put more demands on Social Security and Medicare, will our dependence on narrowly focused, narrowly financed programs unravel what social insurance we have left?
Only consider the efforts of Republicans to repeal Obamacare when they have scarcely concentrated on the supply side reforms which could greatly improve the marketplace. Many calls for a smaller government are simply the desire to move services towards personal preferences in programs and services, instead of actual improvements for Main Street. For the U.S., austerity would likely be the eventual result of gridlock when no one gets their way.

By now, it should be clear that large scale government is too inclined to favor special interests to be effective at managing programs for services. Likewise, state level governments are no panacea for today's services and effective asset formation. Not only have they extended many of the same privileges to special interests, but they are in tenuous positions regarding safety nets as well.

Long term economic growth needs to be explored one privately structured community at a time, so that small successes can be shared, and small failures can become the learning experiences that governments now need. Austerity need not be an inevitable future. Just the same, marketplaces need to make room for greater participation, so that politically defined austerity can give way to a better growth trajectory.

Midweek Market Monetarist Links and Summaries - 3/18/15

And the economy hinges on...patience? (Marcus Nunes) https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/11/key-word/
Abe and Kuroda need to keep the momentum: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/12/central-bankers-and-comfort-zones/
Even as inflation and the dollar continue to move the wrong way... https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/17/the-fed-is-just-like-the-baby-who-cries-i-want-i-want-i-want-because-i-want/
There's no "surprise" in this index: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/17/payroll-numbers-are-the-exception-but-the-fed-is-love-struck-with-them/

(Nick Rowe) Central bankers need to make Say's Law true in practice, even if it is not true in theory: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/03/says-law-and-lump-of-labour.html
Nick responds to David Levine: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/03/david-levines-accidental-monetarism.html

Even Germany "is growing at the pace of a turtle" (Bonnie Carr) https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/03/15/is-the-eurozone-an-optimal-currency-zone/

A $210 trillion "fiscal gap"...(Scott Sumner) Who do you trust, Kotlikoff or the market?
Presently, the major factor is easier money overseas: The rising dollar will not impact US growth
Whatever metric one may use, The euro is still far too strong
At times, Bernanke was willing to speak up: The biggest basher of them all
This stimulus probably wouldn't boost net exports: Apart from boosting NGDP and RGDP, euro depreciation will not help Italy
"Never reason from a price change" is also a part of Econ 101: Krugman on NRFPC
Only one step from Krugman, to Friedman: Brilliant Krugman, dumb leftists
Wait...that's Scott's argument! Krugman on European growth and the euro

Scott at Econlog:
The public needs to know exactly what the Fed is trying to accomplish: Everyone needs to be accountable
Scott highlights a great nineties essay from Krugman: Krugman's dangerous idea (it worked for me too!)
What's the "sell by date" of Krugmanomics?
Repudiation of big spending? We'll believe it when we see it...Will the GOP once again opt for big government

Lars Christensen highlights the open borders manifesto: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/03/16/the-open-borders-manifesto/

Even though households may not be able to afford homes, rents aren't falling (Kevin Erdmann) http://idiosyncraticwhisk.blogspot.com/2015/03/the-road-to-housing-recovery.html
Kevin looks at asset values in the U.S. over time: http://idiosyncraticwhisk.blogspot.com/2015/03/housing-tax-policy-series-part-20-never.html

"Cash in circulation has doubled in the last ten years." (Benjamin Cole) https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/17/cash-in-circulation-a-topic-economists-hate-1-34-trillion-u-s-cash-in-circulation-most-of-it-in-the-usa-up-500-billion-since-2008-doubled-in-10-years/

A circular flow model for income and expenditure (David Glasner) http://uneasymoney.com/2015/03/17/of-bathtubs-drains-and-faucets/

Simon Wren-Lewis worries than an NGDP target is not enough to restore growth: Radical macro lessons from the Great Depression

Tyler Cowen lays out some of the possibilities for Fed tightening: Should we listen to Ray Dalio? Should we taper? Be patient?

Monday, March 16, 2015

Innovation Needs Decentralization

A primary goal of any local knowledge use system, would be to recapture the earlier spontaneity of innovation. Inventions were once associated with specific individuals, and those innovations often proved capable of benefiting populations as a whole. While today's innovations are geared towards internal procedures and long term profits, earlier inventions tended to reinforce previous gains within broad based settings. Future innovation needs more of that same outward, decentralized focus, as a starting point.

What, exactly, about the earlier innovation dynamic has been lost? After some discussion regarding innovation for public welfare, Diane Coyle provided a number of related links in a recent post and she sums up:
(a) we're a long way from being able to make definitive policy recommendations about how to boost innovation...And (b) there's a lot of work economists need to do on standard welfare economics, which has a dusty 1970s (or earlier) feel to it.
It's hard to miss the fact that governments used to be more capable of contributing research for widely held knowledge. Even though no one expects private enterprise to share closely held secrets with the public, tax funded knowledge use was supposed to be a different story. However, governments no longer have adequate reason to publicly support knowledge, in part because they materially gain from privatized knowledge use. Kemal Davis notes for instance that public/private knowledge capture has created its own inequality, with "$84,000 for a twelve-week course of treatment" for hepatitis C.

Unfortunately, the publicly funded capital firms (sovereign wealth funds) which Dani Rodrik suggests for future innovation, would be quite difficult to enact. Kemal Davis also worried that monopolistic industries such as pharmaceuticals "would contribute to the creation of a new aristocracy that can pass on its wealth through inheritance". However, worrying about this particular inheritance possibility is beside the point. What matters is not so much the distribution of already existing wealth, but the fact that important knowledge use flows have been severely disrupted. After all, this impacts wealth creation as a whole.

Even though governments can't travel " back in time" to more inclusive innovation at national or state levels, citizens can do so locally through the creation of knowledge use systems. This would also be a more effective way to address inequality, than centralized forms of innovation which mostly benefit those who coordinate and invest in large scale projects at the outset. More of that commitment and investment - particularly for innovation in services and asset formation - needs to occur locally.

Fortunately, today's technology opens new paths for production to benefit small scale settings - a factor which can make all the difference for local planning. As Alex Tabarrok and Shruti Rajagopalen noted recently, there is a "delicate dance of top-down and bottom-up planning that cities need to thrive".

This "delicate dance" is a process which domestic summits could capture. Those who have new ideas and concepts for infrastructure, would be able to meet with individuals from all walks of life who wish to take part in the process. Most important, the planning component of domestic summits is only the beginning. Innovation is not just about creating unique settings to live and work in, but what happens through the course of lifetimes in these settings as well.

Sunday, March 15, 2015

"Necessary Evil"? Money Is Better Than That

One often hears money referred to as something "dirty" - if necessary! However a new book, "Sapiens", has some positive things to say about money. Arnold Kling highlighted this quote from the author, Yuval Harari:
Money...involved the creation of a new inter-subjective reality that exists solely in people's shared imaginations...money is the most universal and effective system of mutual trust ever devised.
Of course, in saying this, Harari defines a vast stretch of time during which money has transformed the lives of countless individuals. More recently, money has apparently lost some of its earlier luster. Hence Arnold Kling writes,
I like to say that money is a consensual hallucination...What about hyperinflation? Think of that as the government needing to pay for its deficit spending through an enormous counterfeit operation. One that ultimately undermines the trust in money and wrecks the protocol for exchanging goods.
Ouch! Arnold is hardly alone in his musings as to broken trust and broken markets. Did government "ruin" money for us...or government cronies...or both? Nick Rowe provides the "money as necessary evil" response to Sandwichman in a recent post re Say's Law shortcomings:
I can't see any practical way to resort to barter, and make Say's Law true in theory. The cure would be worse than the disease. We seem to be stuck with money. Some monetary regimes are bad, and some are even worse.
Where is the inter-subjective reality which Harari spoke of? Once, it existed in the resources which individuals were able to directly work with, and money often provided a simple augmentation of this process. Now, a marketplace for time is needed. Money needs a chance to further evolve, so that it can fulfill the more personal roles which remain MIA in the economy of the present.

Time based coordination roles have the potential to substitute for the kind of intrinsic wealth which land once provided, prior to twentieth century production gains. That earlier (subsistence based) wealth of land has gradually evolved, into a form of wealth which particularly benefits from societal coordination. Whereas some markets fulfill this process in purely price based terms (i.e. minus time aggregate value), others need compensated time value as well, in order to become and remain viable. Time arbitrage could complete a necessary process of adaptation, for economic orientation towards services and knowledge use.

Money has become problematic in part due to services imbalances, which were superimposed on traditional production and asset formation. Over time, governments have usurped too many time use roles, as they have consolidated production gains from the marketplace. One problem with this process is that governments are forced to define employment based on merit, instead of through the actual time aggregates of given populations.

Consider what happens to societal coordination for instance, when skills value usurps time value in too many circumstance. Governments are not well equipped, to compensate for time value which has not been accounted for in the marketplace.

Local populations can overcome this allocation problem, by treating time aggregates as investment fallback positions in local support systems. One benefit of this process is that populations would not have to use their governments to allot needed services beyond what is already possible. Of late, governments are increasingly falling short in their services based promises, and they have attempted to grant too many favors to associations which define the conditions by which services "must" be produced. Now, aggregate demand and the monetary systems which rely on it, are paying the price.

This is why many individuals need a marketplace for time, in order to regain services and personal values which were lost to arbitrary definitions. It is particularly important to do this before the present marketplace further erodes monetary values in relation to other resources. Once services based aspects of monetary activity come into better balance, money can recapture the role for societal coordination that it held for so long.

A marketplace for time value (equal monetary compensation for mutual time coordination) would go a long way to improve public attitudes about money. How so? Money is capable of supporting value in use endeavor, if and when value in exchange does not provide a complete marketplace. Local communities would generate knowledge use systems which pay local citizens for actively assisting one another in the marketplace. Key in all this is not to deny the value of governmental context, but to find better means to coordinate time use than governments (and other institutions) have been able to provide.

Until it is possible to do so, many will continue to blame money for problems which money was never responsible for in the first place. By reimbursing time arbitrage - instead of cancelling time aggregates in favor of meritocracy - a tremendous amount of skill potential can be brought back into the marketplace. What's more, money will finally have a chance to return to the place where it began: subjective reality.

Saturday, March 14, 2015

Knowledge Use: Supply Creates Its Own Demand

How might one think about knowledge use in terms of supply and Say's Law? Say's Law has been ridiculed at least since the mid 20th century, for understandable if unfortunate reasons. Those of us who believe Say's Law is important, haven't really had adequate means to defend our position, either. For one thing, employment gains which include more substantial knowledge use are possible. The problem? The organizational capacity which would bring these gains within reach, has to occur on more inclusive, decentralized, and yes - equal terms. That's difficult for many to even imagine, particularly in a time when knowledge use has divided and polarized populations.

Nick Rowe explores some aspects of employment potential (after productivity improvements) in a recent post. Something that's often missed in these discussions: many representative groups would lose their own competitive supply side "edge", should full employment be sought in general equilibrium. As a result - instead of imagining full meaningful employment - some would rather reimburse people either for not working at all, or through a marginal position which "threatens" no one. After all, what happens if everyone gets to use knowledge? While automation continues to "eat away" at traditional production, the resulting leisure time appears as though a nebulous given - even though "leisure" for some is akin to torture, for others.

Perhaps this is why some with strong knowledge use affiliation, argue against Say's Law. Why would they want to consider how full employment might actually be possible? And yet, participants of knowledge based endeavor may not always be fully cognizant that they are also part of the supply side - particularly in terms of what is sometimes referred to as effective demand. Might awareness of said effective demand (due to restricted supply) lead to a desire for hard caps on monetary activity? If so, there may be little difference between some progressives and internet Austrians, in the monetary terms of the present. Examples in this regard include conservative physicians who might vote Republican, as well as progressive educators who tend to vote Democrat.

Regarding Nick's (above linked) post: if output gains from production lead to less employment...what then? Until recently, if less employment was needed in order to make things, populations could compensate by expanding employment in knowledge based areas which would augment and assist traditional production - even if only obliquely. Now, this strategy need to be rethought. What happens to knowledge use, if it cannot actively assist traditional production? Does it decline? After all, if employment declines, so too does knowledge use. How does one know a decline would not lead to a precipitous spiral?

One of the main problems in this regard is with time use value. Services decentralization is needed, in order to internalize and capture personal time value which otherwise gets lost in the shuffle. While exclusive knowledge holdings work for both pragmatic and signaling purposes, they force knowledge to adhere to highly specific functions which may not extend to interdisciplinary interpretation. Worse, the subjective value of knowledge which applies to special time and circumstance, is either minimized or discarded. Also lost in all this - a considerable amount of intellectual and personal capacity. Ultimately - without a full marketplace for knowledge use, traditional production gains eventually mean less employment as a whole. As Nick Rowe noted:
The debate has moved on. But we sometimes need to remind ourselves that money is at the root of questions like these. It is a fallacy to assume that a doubling of productivity will automatically cause a 50% decline in unemployment. It depends. It is a fallacy to assume that a doubling of productivity will automatically cause a doubling of the demand for goods. It depends. It depends on preferences, and it depends on money.
I would add that much also depends on a broader societal understanding, as to what is at stake. In other words: knowledge use strategies of the 20th century are in serious need of reconstruction, if the present day economy is to be maintained. Even though monetary policy cannot provide solutions for full employment, it still holds a vital connection with the supply side solutions which populations need to generate on their own.

Artificial knowledge use scarcity is problematic on multiple levels. Special status for knowledge use not only represents wealth capture - it does so in ways which could possibly reverse centuries of progress. This is why it is so important to make knowledge use more egalitarian, before too much present day wealth is undermined. While some knowledge access will always remain exclusive, the survival of universities is already being threatened. This is an important clue which no one can safely ignore: the sooner that knowledge use is approached differently - the better.

Much of traditional production has gradually been moving towards less hierarchical structures, and knowledge use needs to take a similar approach. Today, services are secondary production structures with limited employment capacity. They are also hierarchical in nature, and mostly reimburse centralized knowledge use at administrative levels.

Those who want full employment which includes knowledge use at all levels, need organization which can bring the process to fruition. Closely held knowledge is a revealed preference, in the same manner as any other form of protected employment status. Now, this protected status leaves society hanging in the balance, in terms of economic participation. Demand need not remain limited. But before demand can be freed, supply has to be freed, as well.

Wednesday, March 11, 2015

Midweek Market Monetarist Links and Summaries - 3/11/15

Workers have done "poorly in recent decades"...or have they? (Scott Sumner) Real wage bleg
Defining capitalism as "evil incarnate" doesn't help anything - A new argument against libertarianism
Is Evan Soltas right about the convenience factor? The criminalization of currency and the zero bound
Does tax reform stand a chance? Rubio-Lee is great, so why not make it even greater?
I can relate to Scott's outdoors post - one of life's brighter moments was a trip on the "blue highways" of the U.S. for three months, with a small tent to slip into at night. Who's afraid of the great outdoors?
"Don't raise rates until you see the whites of inflation's eyes." Will the Fed undershoot its inflation target?
"In a better world both parties would agree on an efficient tax regime," Clear thinking about taxes
This economist is no internet Austrian: Russ Roberts interviews Lawrence H. White

Scott at Econlog:
Consumption doesn't get enough consideration: The bizarre way economists calculate real income
Is the "inequality" issue a cover for something else?
Two ways of thinking about economics

Justin Irving now has efficient forecast up and running. The site is here

Obama didn't want to be bothered...(Bonnie Carr) https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/03/04/in-the-mood-for-a-rant-astounding-obama-administration-and-fed-incompetence/

Marcus Nunes compares NGDP in two U.S. districts: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/04/along-i-35-i-9094/
FOMC transcripts - read at your own (health) risk: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/04/the-economy-was-tanking-and-they-played-dumb/
"...real trend growth shifted up after 2003," https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/05/india-a-missed-opportunity/
What "big data" uncovers: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/05/fomc-transcripts-fat-on-inflation-and-thin-on-unemployment/
Job gains! Wait, what? https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/06/ah-cold-comforting-seasons/
Now the Fed wants support from the labor market... https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/06/adrift-but-with-an-attitude/
And the "boost" from a falling LFPR particularly helps: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/07/lackers-homily/
A fiscal story, in graphs: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/08/strange-coincidences-a-graphic-novel/
And the NAIRU band played on...https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/09/the-great-excuse/
Some clarification for Krugman: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/10/krugman-remains-confused/
Will NGDP come back to trend? https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/03/11/im-reluctant-to-criticize-the-excellent-rba-but-they-do-need-to-ease-policy-a-bit/

Interest rates are low because of the economy, not because the Fed wanted them low... (David Beckworth) http://macromarketmusings.blogspot.com/2015/03/negative-interest-rates-zlb-and-true.html
The periphery has been through this before...http://macromarketmusings.blogspot.com/2015/03/fool-me-once-shame-on-you-fool-me-twice.html

Bill Woolsey responds to a WSJ article by Greg Ip: No Good Deflation?
Also, a response to a post from Miles Kimball: Miles Kimball on the Primacy of the Unit of Account

Contrary to Andolfatto, the involuntary aspects are quite real (Nick Rowe): http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/03/involuntary-unemployment-as-worsening-trade-off.html
Nick asks for a little help with the math... http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/03/how-much-of-a-deficit-will-in-fact-be-money-financed.html

(Kevin Erdmann) "If the capital asset pricing model is valid at all, then the potential gains from NGDP targeting are enormous." The huge potential value of NGDP level targeting, a CAPM risk taking perspective
"...if we look at the funding of national production, we really do owe it to ourselves." http://idiosyncraticwhisk.blogspot.com/2015/03/the-equity-mystery-in-2006-2008_11.html

Even Soltas is largely on the "same page" with Paul Krugman and Greg Ip: http://esoltas.blogspot.com/2015/03/more-on-negative-rates.html

Lars Christensen is enthused about Hypermind: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/03/10/prediction-market-fed-on-track-to-hit-4-ngdp-growth-in-2015/

Greg Ip at the WSJ asks, How far below zero can interest rates go?

Tuesday, March 10, 2015

Where Does Commitment Begin?

And are strong commitments presently possible, in an overall sense? What happens when governments and certain business interests insist on economic conditions for their personal enrichment, which are not conducive for a wide majority of citizens to maintain commitments and goals? Perhaps these seem like odd questions, but they matter in part due to reasoning on the part of upper income levels, regarding lower income levels.

All too often, the former don't fully recognize when they set up game boards which don't allow the latter to effectively participate. As a result, "twenty times" the patience might be required of a low income person, as the amount of patience required by someone with high income, to achieve a related outcome in monetary terms. The person who doesn't have to "purchase" patience quite as often, gets a stronger constitution to pass to the next generation. Yet if consumption possibilities were more broadly defined, the additional required patience to achieve lower income goal sets would not be necessary every single time!

Too many basic consumption requirements are defined on mid to high income terms. As a result, a missed single link can break an entire consumption chain which is needed as a combined set, in order for low income individuals to maintain responsibilities. Today the media overreacts to long term psychological effects, on the part of some who found success in poverty's wake by the skin of their teeth - such as sports figures in unfortunate moments of anger with family members. Buying patience too many times in a day is like drinking too many cups of coffee to stay alert - the effect only lasts so long. It's easy to assume that low income individuals have little patience, resolve or commitment, because one can find examples anywhere they look. Furthermore, impatience or broken patience becomes a logical end result, eventually.

Public dialogue has become somewhat odd in this regard. Recent struggles - particularly those regarding race, immigration and protectionism - surface in ways the media "forgets" are related to still lingering economic concerns. Even so, Washington elite became comfortable with economic circumstance at least a year ago. That's when they began to reason that all is well, hence it's time for everyone to "buck up" and take care of themselves. For instance, the Fed has dreamed of returning to normalcy, practically since the Great Recession began. Now, their earlier monetary commitments are finally coming to an end and "liftoff" is imminent. Normal NAIRU is the latest fad, hence anyone such as myself who remains concerned about lagging labor force participation rate is just a scoundrel, according to progressives such as Bill McBride.

Even so, political campaigns are digging for some government commitment "crumbs" to offer up to the population. The latest reasoning? Some conservatives are realizing that - oh my yes - success in life depends on one's ability to form strong and lasting commitments. This further seems to suggest tax breaks in particular for children whose families were "smart enough" to remain intact. God willing, maybe these incentives will nicely align and the pieces will fit...

Many lower income individuals are quite the same as anyone: they want to commit to life goals, for this is the most human of desires. But not everyone has the same degree of strength or good fortune, to respond to the way major consumption definitions are set by governments and special interests. How does one make long term commitments to goalposts which are purposely placed out of reach of everyone but the strong? And yet one is ultimately judged for the fact they fall short of the goal time and again. Where was the consideration, for the fact a singular societal goalpost might possibly have been unreasonable in the first place.

None of this is a matter of calculated tax tweaks and indignant calls for higher income levels. No tax tweak or income level is ever going to catch up with temptation on the part of governments and some businesses as well, to manipulate certain consumer definitions beyond reasonable hope for lower income levels. Every tax tweak, income increase and arbitrary consumer definition further enriches governments and their crony friends, even as these tactics further impoverish citizens. Will anyone really fool themselves into believing humankind can remain strong by encouraging environments purposely designed to remain out of reach of the weak? In a recent blog post, Adam Gurri wrote these words,
I don't think it's possible to have a good life without commitment. 
Indeed. Indeed. First, do no harm. Do no harm.