Thursday, April 16, 2020

Flexible Building Components Could Save Lives

Once extensive manufacturing innovation finally kicks in, flexible components might even make home ownership feasible with only an income of $12,000 per year. At least one can hope! Importantly, many different groups are closer to this level of income than it may seem, not to mention the fixed incomes of Social Security checks. Clearly, calls for "living wages" will continue, if our non tradable sectors are not able to build real wage potential via production reform.

Recall also, that $1,000 a month is a frequently cited basic income possibility, in the event of technological employment disruption. But what would basic income accomplish, if non discretionary needs are mostly out of reach? Alas, this level of income, significant though it may be for the provider, still leaves recipients too dependent on the assistance of others. Without a concerted non tradable sector response, millions could remain unable to create useful and productive lives for themselves. Indeed, deaths of despair often stem from such realities.

However, the pandemic provides a more straightforward example, how independent living made possible by flexible components, could save lives. As it turns out, the most dangerous transmission of the virus occurs via households where people regularly congregate under the same roof. According to medrxiv:
All identified outbreaks of three or more cases occurred in an indoor environment, which confirms that sharing indoor space is a major SARS-CoV-2 infection risk.
Even though transmission takes many different forms, repeated social interactions at close range is particularly dangerous due to increased viral loads. Consequently, healthcare practitioners often attempt to isolate themselves from family members, when risk of infection is exceptionally high. Yet being able to do so is not always easy. Indeed, some physicians make temporary living quarters in backyard tents, to mitigate the risks to their own families. At the very least, individuals sometimes loan recreational vehicles and travel trailers to healthcare workers, where zoning permits them to do so. Other communities are stepping in and providing hotel rooms for much needed isolation, as well.

Besides addressing these short term realities, flexible building components could also prove well suited for a longer term context. A recent Brookings article notes how the crisis only exacerbates the problems low income groups already faced, in their efforts to secure reliable employment and housing. All too often, when extensive virus transmission occurs under one roof, it is partly the result of individuals having doubled up with other family members, after they experienced difficulties tending to obligations on their own.

Not every community is willing to make room for mobility options in living and working needs, and NIMBY impulses will doubtless remain one of life's constants. Still, some communities may decide to take a new and constructive approach. Clearly, the same market potential which opens ownership capacity for a wider range of income levels, makes room for new definitions of dynamic community in the process. Should flexible building components be adopted in the near future, these ownership options could help create paths which lead away from the uncertainties of the pandemic. With a little luck, flexible housing manufacture might become one of the initial ways that societies overcome the economic uncertainties of pandemic times.

Saturday, April 11, 2020

Three Basic Ingredients for Economic Stability

While there are many ways to envision what contributes to economic stability, the current pandemic suggests a closer look at basic ingredients. Should it prove difficult to maintain current wealth levels, a focus on the essentials could also lead to sturdier safety net options. I find it useful to think about three elements in particular: First, the importance of stabilizing what is nominal. Then, building a simpler framing for physical and non physical aspects of the real economy which the nominal represents.

As a market monetarist, I also believe it is vital to maintain a level nominal target, so that general equilibrium will (hopefully) remain stabilized. And even though level NGDP targeting is not the stated approach of the Fed, central bankers have more closely adhered to nominal stability since the mistakes of the Great Recession. The greater danger now, however, is that monetary stabilization could be threatened by extensive supply side disruptions. Adjusting for optimal aggregate demand will be quite the challenge, since present supply side uncertainties - unlike many previous shocks to the real economy - are due to factors too numerous to understand.

Consequently, despite what it can accomplish in the near future, monetary policy still needs to adjust to lost general equilibrium capacity, at some point. In other words, accurate nominal representation also depends on what the real economy is able to accomplish. Clearly, there is a great deal of interdependence between the nominal realm, the physical realm, and human oriented aspects of our economic lives.

Again, consider what present uncertainty consists of, insofar as many chains of financial obligation are being disrupted. How will society respond? Understandably, fiscal policy also seeks to stabilize general equilibrium conditions. Nevertheless, doing so is only feasible up to a point. All the more so, when fiscal stabilization attempts to include many activities that are not essential to getting things done.

In all of this, many small businesses won't survive, and some Main Streets could end up even less dynamic than before. For instance, one third of Americans missed their rent payments in April. This means problems for renters and landlords alike. Stephen Cecchetti and Kermit Schoenholtz explain what financial institutions also face:
Banks will not be able to dodge the financial fallout. Many borrowers are likely to suspend repayment soon, presaging widespread default. We will not know the extent of the damage or who will ultimately bear the costs, for some time.
Yet this time really is different, as they further note:
Rather than the financial system undermining the real economy, it is very much the other way around. With few exceptions (like Sweden), advanced economies have entered a form of suspended animation. As a result, households and business are losing income that they can never replace. The hope is that the COVID-19 crisis does not trigger a full-fledged financial crisis, exacerbating what is already destined to be the most severe global downturn since the 1930s. 
Many households and businesses are going to need financial options in the foreseeable future, which rely on lower monthly expense levels. Hence when considering basic ingredients for economic stability, simplification of everyday living circumstance is key to making this possible. By way of example, in my most recent post , I suggested flexible building and infrastructure options as a way to address structural physical aspects of the real economy.

Likewise, broader options for economic participation and use of human capital, are needed for non physical aspects of our environments. We need locally applied time arbitrage, to rescue what are increasingly endangered knowledge chains. Two recent articles offer unsettling examples. From NPR:
According to a report released this month by the Chartis Center for Rural Health, nearly half of rural hospitals were already operating in the red before the COVID-19 crisis.
Further, Dylan Scott writes for Vox that hospitals are cutting staff "just when America needs them most". Even though the initial healthcare losses took place largely outside of hospitals, staff cuts are beginning to spread inside of these institutions. Only recall that much of this problem stems from the fact today's healthcare is heavily dependent on existing wealth - much of which is in jeopardy at least in the short term.

Let's create simpler procedures and settings for ownership and economic participation, so that individuals and businesses aren't jeopardized every time a month's revenues fall short. Ultimately, we could end up struggling to maintain general equilibrium in its present configuration. But even if existing wealth is somehow diminished, imagine what could still be done, to strengthen and preserve its core.

Why not make our physical and non physical environments easier to access for all concerned. If we can shake loose structural rigidities how productive activities are "supposed" to occur, oppressive financial burdens could be lightened as well. A direct structural approach today, would be better than the indirect response of a debt jubilee later on. Perhaps debt jubilees of the past also reflected the unwillingness of societies to relax their own expectations for working and living requirements. Debt jubilees may have been no real panacea, if they left in place the same rigid requirements that negated the economic participation of millions - even in good times. Let's work on reducing unnecessary barriers to ownership and economic participation, so that a better new normal might eventually emerge.

Monday, April 6, 2020

It's Time to Build Strong, Lightweight, Yet Affordable

As the financial repercussions of the pandemic gradually set in, more of us will become focused on "whatever it takes" to keep a roof over our heads. Towards this end, flexible building components of all kinds are needed - especially for anyone already experiencing difficulties with rent and mortgage costs before the pandemic even began. The more mobile options we have for physical infrastructure and buildings in the near future, the greater our chances of continued economic stability.

Where to start? Initially, until 3D printing becomes more widespread for local manufacture, building components and their associated infrastructure, could be designed and implemented in various locations around the country. Once these new markets start to go into effect, they would gradually assume retail connections in communities which can open their doors to the appropriate zoning and regulatory variance. I continue to hope that plastics manufacturers are already experimenting with materials suited for these purposes. Plus, the more plastics in production which can be recycled locally for more building materials and infrastructure, the better.

In contrast with the response of temporary fiscal stimulus for businesses and employment losses, affordable building components would be a gift that keeps on giving, via lower monthly financial obligations. And even though affordable building components can especially help lower income levels, they would also provide means to "start fresh", for many who face temporary setbacks due to the economic circumstance of the pandemic.

Ownership of flexible building components could take place incrementally. The most basic starter units, for instance, would include built in (manufactured) electrical and plumbing. This would be an especially important regulatory variance, since the costs of normally required skilled labour for electrical and plumbing, tend to prevent home ownership for those with limited income. These costs stand in the way of lower income levels being able to purchase traditional homes which are in extensive need of repair and renovation.

Initially, communities could connect building components with already existing infrastructure such as electrical lines and local water systems. However, an eventual community goal in many instances would be to create more flexible infrastructure options for energy, water and sewer needs. Only recall that when land can be used in ways which allow it to revert to simpler, less costly uses afterward (such as agriculture), temporary use zoning could prove simpler than zoning changes which require permanently higher land use costs.

Chances are, in the near future, job losses will make it difficult for millions of individuals to meet what are continuous financial obligations - particularly rent. Even though fiscal stimulus will provide temporary relief, it comes at the cost of additional long term budgetary burdens. What is really needed, is a long term approach for economic stability which does not create additional financial burdens. New patterns for incremental ownership, could create a targeted response to the uncertainties brought about by the current pandemic.

Tuesday, March 31, 2020

Wrap Up for March 2020

"Useful writing makes claims that are as strong as they can be made without becoming false."

There are similarities between bank runs and public contagions.
"The challenge of re-establishing public confidence that it is safe to venture out bears striking similarity to the one that authorities face in stemming a bank run. Our ability to identify and quarantine people infected with COVID-19 is analogous to our ability to recognize and isolate a bank bordering on insolvency."

NGDP fluctuations are sometimes logical in relatively uncommon supply side recessions.

Mark Koyama reviews Escape From Rome.

$175 billion in improper payments.

James Pethokoukis and Branko Milanovic discuss what future capitalism might look like.

The speed at which ideas are adopted, depend in part on how quickly their effects can be ascertained.

Perhaps the momentum to put an end to single house zoning is starting to build.

Hal Varian considers the future of technology, with James Pethokoukis.

It would not be a good idea to give rights of ownership to artificial intelligence.

"Can physician assistants help solve America's rural health care problem?"

Technology is not just an exogenous force that exists outside of ourselves. It could also be utilized to improve the skill sets we already have. "A fundamental reason why society under-invests in innovations that benefit ordinary people has to do with the distribution of power."

Arnold Kling reviews 10% Less Democracy by Garrett Jones.

"the COVID-19 crisis is hitting the world economy when growth is already soft and countries are wildly overleveraged."

More than ever, the Fed needs to "stabilize the growth of nominal gross domestic product."

Some basic economics for U.S. healthcare.

How do markups affect knowledge diffusion?

For all the value GDP holds as a measure, it is still incomplete for what nations would like to express.

Arnold Kling details costs of production for Econlib.

Given all the depressing news re COVID-19 of late, this 3D printed neighbourhood was one of the recent bright spots.

James Capretta looks at policies which affect the number of physicians in the U.S.

Greg Mankiw offers his thoughts re the pandemic.

Even though monetary policy can't solve the coronavirus crisis, it can prevent secondary effects.

Kevin Bryan explains the economics of social distancing.

Tim Harford reviews Uncharted by Margaret Heffernan.

"The 1920s were the decade of leisure because people could afford to relax. The 1930s were the era of frantic problem solving because people had no other choice."

Healthcare systems now need to surf the curve.

Timothy Taylor highlights a working paper, re potential lessons from the "Spanish Flu" a century earlier.

Bryan Caplan shares methods by which he gradually learned to reduce more than twenty years of chronic pain.

"This pandemic could stall or reverse American urbanization." Joel Kotkin also notes how pandemics function as a deterrent to urban life.

The challenge of a supply shock, is ensuring that follow on reductions in demand don't lead to additional cycles of contractionary shocks.

3D printers are finding ways to help healthcare workers.

Coronavirus will also disrupt intermediate goods and services production. And, how do shocks in some industries affect other industries?

Carmen Reinhart believes we lack historical comparisons for how the pandemic could ultimately unfold.

A useful guide for emergency homeschooling.

State and local governments are not a part of the new big lending programs.

Centralized healthcare systems are ill suited for pandemics. Many patients could be treated at home, a process which would also reduce the spread.

A list of policy proposals to mitigate virus impact, from Tyler Cowen.

"The real pandemic danger is social collapse." Also, labour demand is undergoing a dramatic shift.

Joshua Gans explains production possibilities in a time of pandemic.

Rural areas which are popular for tourists are vulnerable now, other rural areas are likely to be more vulnerable later on.

"Longer-run economic consequences of pandemics"

"the lower the amount of medical infrastructure, the longer it takes to build immunity."

The Mercatus Center suggests a way forward.

Explaining the rationale for social insurance payments.

Many of us will be reexamining our present and near future projects in the months ahead.

"in lower-income countries the notion of employment through firms cannot be taken for granted"

Emergency reforms have provided a little additional supply side capacity.

Addressing the pandemic in four phases.

The recent shock goes beyond what stress tests are normally expected to gauge.

"How many jobs can be done at home?"

Saturday, March 28, 2020

Some Considerations re Economic Stability

Already it is evident that pandemics don't provide easy answers, when it comes to maintaining economic stability. How to know, who or what could most benefit from assistance over extended periods? Appropriate fiscal policy is no easy feat, yet governments have few options to directly address workplace losses which have occurred practically overnight.

Granted, fiscal support for pressing healthcare needs will remain crucial in the immediate future. Access to testing and other vital services, will also play roles in the time it takes to regain normalcy. But while support for healthcare systems is paramount, some aspects of financial stabilization may not prove optimal in the months ahead.

Determining where financial stabilization could help most, is even more difficult in a time of growing budgetary pressures and extensive long term debt obligations. Hence two questions on many minds at state and local levels, basically come down to this: Which spending options are discretionary? Or, which spending is absolutely essentially for individuals, firms and organizations - regardless of what happens? It helps to recall that while fixed production costs are generally associated with private firms, individuals and families have relatively close equivalents, in many instances.

Washington has finally completed its deliberations for a massive stimulus package, yet this might only be the first. For example, James Pethokoukis expressed concern that the current round of fiscal stimulus may only address a months' worth of necessities.

Fiscal assistance for supply side losses is all the more challenging, since policy makers are tasked with taking the fixed costs of businesses and citizens alike, into consideration. Still, governments still have little choice but to pick favorites, with a fiscal policy approach. Even now, there are ways in which monetary policy functions more efficiently, to "get in the cracks" where fixed cost remedies can't be readily ascertained.

Nevertheless, monetary policy will face its own challenges, due to extensive supply side disruptions from millions of people staying at home. Given this reality, will central bankers remain willing, to preserve full monetary representation at present capacity? In particular, rising unemployment is going to be a real issue in coming months. A record 3.28 million workers filed for unemployment last week, and as the WSJ noted, "The long run of American job growth has ended." Gred Mankiw adds further perspective from data compiled on hourly employees. Already, "hours worked by hourly employees is down by more than 50 percent", and this is approximately 60% of the labour force.

Fortunately, there are improvements to unemployment claim processes in the stimulus package, which will provide additional access for small businesses and the self employed. With a little luck, once people start to return to their workplaces and the economy begins to improve, today's short term fiscal assistance can gradually transition to the broader stabilization methods of monetary policy.

Will monetary policy prove capable of restoring long term growth, once employment levels normalize? Hopefully, yes. Just the same, perhaps better methods are needed, which can take into account the non discretionary obligations which all citizens face, regardless of workplace participation levels. These non discretionary obligations are vital to general equilibrium dynamics, and the act of recognizing them, might better ensure that full monetary representation continues to take place. Non discretionary fixed costs in our daily lives, are an important focus of current fiscal policy. But hopefully, a broader range of non discretionary obligations will gain prominence in monetary policy, once fiscal remedies are no longer necessary.

Saturday, March 21, 2020

Utilitarian Capitalism (Could Be) Anti-Fragile

How sturdy will our capitalist systems prove to be, in a time of international pandemic? More specifically, are our present day organizational structures more fragile than we previously imagined?

If only it were possible to address this crisis with more utilitarian options, additional fiscal stimulus might prove worthwhile. Instead, most current fiscal stimulus - other than provisions for pressing healthcare needs - will scarcely alleviate the financial burdens which emerge during the course of this pandemic. And unfortunately, too much of our non tradable sector capacity is structured in ways that are profoundly anti-utilitarian. A lot of fiscal stimulus is going to be lost to portions of the economy which are not basic to getting things done, in the days ahead.

In recent decades, much of our supply side capacity became focused on experiential and "quality product" markets. While these markets are valuable, all too often they leave few options for lower income citizens - as consumers - to meet life's basics first. For the most part, our non tradable sectors chose anti-utilitarian routes, in that they were largely designed to create the greatest good for the least number of participants. As governments come to the aid of these now (unexpectedly?) fragile systems, policy makers will find it difficult to meet the needs of their most vulnerable citizens. Unfortunately, the sum total of fiscal stimulus in the days ahead, will create additional debt burdens which still don't address overall economic stability or a safety net for lower income levels.

Eventually, people are likely to demand more basic and utilitarian systems than we presently have, for what are largely non discretionary needs. As Arnold Kling noted in a recent post, "Normal is not an option...Expect supply chains in the future to have a lot more redundancy and to be less driven by cost minimization." An important challenge, however, is to also preserve wealth and productive economic complexity as best we can. The sooner we bring a more utilitarian and flexible approach to our non tradable sector markets, the better.

Regular readers know how much I've praised tradable sector activity in general, since much of its dynamism stems from a uniquely utilitarian impulse. How so? Tradable sectors tend to create the greatest economic good for the greatest number, via product options which represent all income categories, not just those of the middle and upper classes. This is a profound utilitarian result which underlies the prosperity of the recent era we have mostly taken for granted.

But achieving such results in our domestic settings, would mean a refusal to arbitrarily limit supply side definitions in (mostly) non discretionary markets. Until non tradable sectors gain some room to breathe freely, our economic systems are going to become increasingly fragile. Alas, it has finally become evident that strict adherence to specific definitions of quality product, costs lives. At a White House conference earlier this week, Dr. Deborah Birx defended our late start in diagnostics testing for COVID-19, and in doing so she often repeated the need for "quality" product. I must have cringed every time she did so. While the quest to allow only "quality" product is understandable, unfortunately it has led to fragile and incomplete markets, especially in housing and the use of time centered knowledge and skill.

Only recall for example, how continuous calls for quality product eventually led to losses of healthcare provision in rural areas. David McCullough wrote in The Pioneers that when Dr. Samuel Hildreth settled in Marietta, Ohio (1808), the town had "about 180 dwelling houses, and nearly 1500 inhabitants". Yet Dr. Hildreth would be sharing his new practice with five other doctors who were already there!

In all of this, there are both physical and intellectual dimensions to the kinds of utilitarian markets which are urgently needed. Once we finally open the participation of applied knowledge to all citizens, we may also gain greater chances of surviving pandemics. Likewise, should we decide to build a full range of living options representative of all income levels, utilitarian capitalism could come to the rescue of both lives and financial systems. Granted, all such efforts will take time. But it is worth pursuing them now, to make a difference for personal and economic stability in the years to come.

Monday, March 16, 2020

A Kind of Isolation I Scarcely Expected

Presently, everything is in too much flux with the emerging pandemic, to make realistic calls on what may actually happen in the near future. At any rate, this post is mostly observations how it all feels right now. Believe me, I especially feel for those experiencing difficulties in their efforts to observe social distancing. Even though - at 65 - I've had ample time to adjust to relative social isolation, it can still be depressing at times. While there are plenty of ways to cope, it will take time before each individual can determine what works best for them.

Meanwhile online, a do something/anything impulse is going into hyperdrive. Despite the proposed fixes and "solutions" of various observers, much about the pandemic will doubtless remain outside of anyone's control. And even if outcomes could somehow be effectively managed, who would determine, what the most important societal priorities actually are? As Diane Coyle noted in a review of Dark Data, "sometimes the uncertainty is irreducible, as we are learning now." An old song comes to mind, "Que Sera Sera", whatever will be, will be.

Much of my grocery stockpiling took place a few weeks earlier, once I realized the early stage asymptomatic aspect of COVID-19 would likely lead to community spread. Fortunately where we are, I can still venture out for fresh grocery items. I finally bought a sturdy wagon which makes it possible to fill up water jugs when I'm out walking. That's a lot easier than having to rely on the old truck sitting in the garage, which is nearing the end of its useful life. I'm also surprised what a relief it is, to be able to bring the wagon inside the store, in part because no wiping down of grocery cart handles is necessary.

Even now, some public officials remain reluctant to discuss the asymptomatic nature of COVID-19 spread, despite its importance. I also found cause to question some of the public official complaints about hoarding. Granted, a few people are going out and buying too much toilet paper at one time. Nevertheless, plenty of grocery store hoarding is quite rational, given the fact no one knows how long it would be best to remain relatively isolated. Indeed, given the amount of conflicting information in the news, I appreciated this defense of toilet paper hoarders from Marketwatch. Too many warnings from the authorities are incomplete and often devoid of appropriate context.

Also, some of the usual arguments about price gouging don't readily apply, since current circumstance could go beyond the simple one off effects of hurricanes or natural disasters. Rather than raising prices on the most sought after items, grocery chains are generally more inclined to use such items as "loss leaders" to encourage other buying while the customer is in the store. It's only as more people have become aware of impending social distancing, that store shelves are temporarily emptying before they can be restocked the next day.

Hence time considerations are important for what we ultimately pay. By the time I finally decided to get extra bottled waters, so had everyone else. So now I'm more likely to pay full price for bottled water, as the less expensive loss leaders and their pricier substitutes are both flying off the shelves. As supply chains become further disrupted, some grocery stores might need to revert to basic offerings (less product variety) for a longer period of time than is generally necessary with one off interruptions.

Some of my own initial anxieties dissolved into relief, once people where I live began to realize the reality of the pandemic threat. Being in a relatively rural area, we didn't have the panic shopping which led to completely empty store shelves, such as more heavily populated areas have experienced. What gives me hope, however, is that earlier skepticism and denial appears to be giving way to a broader understanding that we are all in this together. Now that's a really good feeling, for if it can be preserved, it might just help us through many of the uncertainties which lie ahead.