Friday, February 27, 2015

A Response For Branko Milanovic

Admittedly I'm a bit slow to directly respond to the initial post he wrote earlier this month, that triggered the recent online discussion.* However, what I need to specifically suggest is that - rather than ditch the term "human capital" - it needs to be embraced and recognized more broadly. Without greater application of human capital, long term growth and prosperity will become increasingly difficult. This, and the remaining fact there's a pressing need to include those who are still forgotten in the marketplace. Presently, human capital is mostly tapped on terms which limit the wealth capacity of time aggregates. Consider Milanovic, here:
Whether using Marxian or neoclassical economic theory, people with greater skills are supposed to be paid more because they produce greater value.
Even though this process made sense for a long time; a point has been reached where everyone's human capital needs to become viable, in order to maintain both sustainability and the present day economy. Only consider that even supporters of the left were forced to create a separate and lower skills compensation path at university levels. This process of income separation at higher skill levels can only continue, particularly as a gradual monetary tightening process by central bankers since the Great Recession, leaves both university administrators and CEOs alike, little choice.

As a result, the need to monetarily compensate those with long educational commitments, has left too little room for growth in the remainder of the marketplace - particularly as services growth has outpaced other forms of production for some time. And yet some still have little access to services. It should be the right of lower income levels to create needed services for themselves, when those who are compensated for high skills have little choice but to mostly provide services for middle to upper class levels.

Also: even though employment appears as though greatly improved of late, consider how labor force participation rates have changed for the worse in the U.S. As Timothy Taylor recently wrote (and his graphs particularly deserve note) the LFPR for prime age working males and females continues to decline in the U.S. relative to other countries. Here's Taylor:
For men, the U.S. was middle-of-the-pack in labor force participation rates of prime-age males in 1990, and now vies with Italy for the lowest level. For women, the U.S. was near the top-of-the-pack prime-age labor force participation in 1990, but since then has been surpassed by France, Canada, Germany and the United Kingdom, and is now about even with Japan--which has not been historically known as a country with high labor force participation for women.
What is especially noteworthy regarding women, is what this says about the "rise" of the healthcare marketplace relative to the rest of the economy. Even with the large presence of women in healthcare, their representation in the marketplace continues to decline! How does one get decreased labor force participation for women, when healthcare continues to grow as a percentage of GDP? This demonstrates the fact that healthcare cannot be expected to substitute for other marketplace factors indefinitely. After all, if people do not have sufficient jobs other than healthcare, they in turn are less able to pay for healthcare as presently defined in the marketplace, when they need it.

Does the claim that human capital isn't important, also imply that the political left can hardly be held responsible for further job creation? If this is part of the reasoning behind the latest volley from the left, I can understand Milanovic's frustration in that it echoes my my own. Job creation was particularly recognized as the responsibility of the right, after the devastating setback of the Great Recession. After all, economic prosperity on supply side terms and a supportive monetary foundation are necessary, before fiscal flows can be maintained for their contributions to job formation. Only consider the difficulty Washington now has with continued funding for DHS, even in a time frame when the economy is supposedly doing "swell". Therefore, the last paragraph from a post by Bryan Caplan back in 2013, "The Grave Evil of Unemployment", appears especially timely now:
I'm proud to call myself a free-market economist. But free market economics can and should improve. Our cavalier and callous attitudes about unemployment are deeply misguided. Free market economists should eagerly share their insights on how to alleviate the grave evil of unemployment, instead of putting their heads in the sand and calling idle misery "optimal."
It is clear that some among the right remember the intent of his message, for these individuals continue to carry the banner for full economic access, even now. Just the same, too many have long forgotten what is still at stake. Bryan wrote those words at a time when people still hoped the supply side would take care of important structural issues - issues which diminish the value of human capital. However, instead of doing their part to assist with structural reform, some simply benefited from monetary easing - even as they derided what economic gains there were, after the fact.

I didn't point out Caplan's earlier post to demean the supply side, but simply to point out that much responsibility for structural employment gains ultimately rests with them, and the contractual agreements they expect governments to provide on their behalf. Granted, monetary policy and supply side coordination are necessary, before fiscal activity can continue its meaningful role. But long lasting gains are dependent on the willingness of everyone in the marketplace to do their part for continued progress. Economic activity ultimately rests and relies on structural considerations which have less to do with tax shifting, than complete economic access in the marketplace.

Hence I view any urge to remove human capital from the vocabulary, as a desire from the left of being absolved of the responsibility of today's remaining unemployment. What's more, some among the right have thrown the ball back in the court of the left prematurely, when the left scarcely had the means to provide the jobs that were still needed.

In short - contrary to Milanovic's reasoning - the full use of human capital is more necessary than ever. Without it, societies end up with an impasse by which neither governments or business interests are willing to forge ahead with continued economic prosperity. Indeed, that is what has occurred in the present. All I am really suggesting is that it serves little purpose to throw up one's hands and insist that we cannot rely on our own intellect and personal capacity, to assist in overcoming the economic impasse of our times.

*For any new readers, I have written several posts this month which further detail my approach for human capital and time use potential this month. They are listed below:

Human Capital: The Missing Anchor
Human Capital Also Holds Value in Use
Human Capital Needs a Time Based Marketplace

Thursday, February 26, 2015

More Musings on Human Capital

Recently I wrote about the importance of human capital from a value in use perspective. It's not enough to think about human capital strictly in value in exchange terms, for this is only part of the mechanism by which individuals - given the chance - make use of knowledge and resources in their environments. Why is value in use activity so important? This (applied) form of human capital allows endogenous or internal social formation. In turn, these social structures have the potential to augment the (necessarily limited) skills and knowledge sets sought by today's institutions.

For instance, value in use contributions are beneficial in that they allow young and old to maintain strong identity formation. Both groups have complained (in their own way) for decades, of the often patronizing consumer functions now assigned to them by an adult based, value in exchange work world. And yet who has heard? Instead, police have been called into the schools, medications are prescribed to keep students "in line", and senior citizens are simply handed more papers to sign, particularly when they are sick.

Of course, senior citizens get their "calming" medications, too. Yet how can any senior citizen be expected to "behave", when already they may not have not been expected to fully reciprocate or participate with others, for decades? Unfortunately, the value in exchange perspective, capable of rewarding primarily "the best" in the workplace, has gradually led to belittlement of old and young alike. What's more, this not only limits identity and potential economic contribution, the process places unnecessary burdens on adult populations, to care for both.

Value in use functions have a practical nature, and can provide needed services at informal levels on time based terms. The time value we assign individuals for human capital value, need not be the same as what institutions assign individuals who gain time value from set educational standards. Given the chance, people would seek one another out for topics and activities which encompass all walks of life. This shouldn't be any surprise, for anyone who remembers the earlier diversity and complexity of subject matter once held in libraries and bookstores across the U.S.

Time use quality has an endogenous nature which is different for all individuals, which is why investment and income strategies need to be different for everyone concerned. Value in exchange understandably focuses on those who utilize time most productively with a short time frame. However, knowledge value also comes from those who take ten times longer to produce a (knowledge based) product than the norm, for instance. That product might hold considerable value which exists independently of the time investment involved.

One aspect of self employment is the fact no one knows ahead of time whether investment in any form of capital will pay off, from a value in exchange perspective. For individuals with little wealth, it is sometimes better to attempt value in exchange investment which also holds value in the fallback terms of value in use. Once, homes provided fallback in this capacity, in that they could offer both value in use and also space for much needed value from personal exchange with others.

A major problem with present day zoning - for instance - is that it has become more difficult for people to invest in value in exchange endeavor which also holds a personal value in use component as a fallback measure. By way of example, if forced to choose between owning a business and a house, some would gladly choose the business, and yet they can't live on the business premises (how many have slept there at night anyway?). Too many people - especially those who may not have been self employed - automatically assume investment of any kind as some boring and reliable function. Indeed, sometimes this gets expressed in ways that make me want to pull my hair out. (Minskyites I'm looking at you...)

Uncertainty of investment for lower income levels in value in exchange terms, is one of the reasons I question investment and savings models which attempt to delineate what "specifically" happens for investment. No one knows until they try! Even activities which may appear as little more than simple consumption represent personal investment to some degree, particularly after one experiences major setbacks. Why? Because there are multiple forms of consumption one becomes less willing to sacrifice for, if it doesn't appear those consumption decisions can still meaningfully contribute to ongoing goals. Automobiles are but one major example.

Value in use environments offer more diverse complexity for human capital and time use, than what has become possible in too many value in exchange settings. For instance, individuals once coordinated time in ways that they could accomplish multiple activities at the same time, particularly when different generations lived and worked in closer quarters. This wasn't multitasking, this was just normal life!

Perhaps knowledge use systems and the time value in use they hold, might even be thought of in numerical terms. Recently, Brad Delong pointed to the fact that only three workers out of ten are needed to produce the goods we consume. When one considers that fiscal activity became a natural flow of monetary activity, it becomes evident that - if government is particularly efficient - they may expect to generate another three workers to match the initial (production) three which Delong spoke of. Basically, knowledge use value for production value, right? Unfortunately, this mostly works for middle to upper income level services.

What about the remaining four positions which are needed to generate a complete services marketplace? It is not reasonable or possible to expect business to give up profits to create work for those four as well, especially given the fact business paved the way for efficient governments to match three for three. Plus, business creates profit by selecting the "best" human capital...ahh, oh well. That leaves four working positions of every ten, which could generate a starting point for a directly compensated, value in use economy. Value in exchange investment and consumption for the formerly excluded, can then go a long way to make the difference for long term growth. There is no single time investment ratio to other forms of capital investment ratio, because no one knows in advance how much time will be required for the product they want most to present to the public.

Brad Delong suggested "Making Do With More", for Project Syndicate. Why not go much further than "making do", by making time aggregates truly optimal? Value in exchange needs value in use, in order to remain whole and viable. No one need be diminished, just because their perceived (exogenous) value isn't as "great" as those whose knowledge gains augmentation from economies of scale.

Wednesday, February 25, 2015

Midweek Market Monetarist Links and Summaries - 2/25/15

Would countries hold themselves accountable, if they independently printed their own money? (Nick Rowe) http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/fixed-exchange-rates-and-blame-thy-neighbour.html
When supply side factors reduce potential equilibrium: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/keynesian-cross-as-simultaneous-moves-symmetric-nash-equilibrium.html
More Greek questions from Nick: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/do-the-greeks-need-greek-banks.html
Human capital in traditional value in exchange context: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/ours-the-task-eternal-investing-in-human-capital.html
More capital questions: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/does-capital-income-exist.html
He seems to recognize "Divine Coincidence" has failed. But what might that mean? http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/steve-poloz-on-inflation-targeting.html

Lots of blogging from Josh Hendrickson this week:
https://everydayecon.wordpress.com/2015/02/18/germany-greece-and-rent-seeking/
https://everydayecon.wordpress.com/2015/02/19/resolving-the-glasner-sumner-dispute/
https://everydayecon.wordpress.com/2015/02/20/more-on-germany/

"Unambiguously positive?" Hmm...(Britmouse) https://uneconomical.wordpress.com/2015/02/19/the-supply-shock-is-coming-in-2016/

Choke demand, and supply will follow (Marcus Nunes): https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/18/demand-supply-are-intertwined/
In Greece, a drop in unit labor costs hasn't eased unemployment: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/19/what-price-success-2/
Strong U.S. dollar? Who cares! https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/21/mr-bullard-is-in-a-hurry/
Was this really the best headline the WSJ could come up with?? https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/23/oscar-for-best-headline-in-the-reasoning-from-a-price-change-category/
"Celebrating" deflation? https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/23/oscar-for-best-editorial-punch-line-in-the-monetary-policy-target-category/
Until 2011, all was well...https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/23/poland-never-really-understood-why-it-didnt-crash-in-2008/
Matt O'Brien's analysis is a bit convoluted: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/24/a-price-is-never-guilty-of-anything-its-just-a-variable-that-reflects-its-fundamental-determinants/
There are good reasons why structural reform on fiscal terms is wishful thinking: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/24/in-greenspan-rubin-had-his-wizard/

This Economist article advocates level targeting (Scott Sumner) The Economist on good and bad deflation
The textbook description can be confusing: What does MV=PY actually mean?
More musings on Greece: The burden of history
Why aren't students taught more than what is already obvious, about real world circumstance? Nobody understands that nobody understands supply and demand
Already, the Swiss stock market has regained most of its losses: Why Switzerland is such a great country (all's well that ends well)
How to talk about shares of growth? Beware of income inequality data
At Econlog, Scott highlights a post from Kevin Erdmann: The housing bubble: perceptions and reality
Inequality? It's not just about education (Econlog): Power is a residual

From Lipsey's essay on national income (David Glasner) http://uneasymoney.com/2015/02/20/why-theories-of-national-income-based-on-accounting-identities-are-nonsensical-and-error-ridden-part-i/

Want to encourage a more growth oriented Fed? Benjamin Cole provides some contact info: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/22/can-president-obama-yet-appoint-2-and-811ths-of-the-12-fomc-members-maybe/
What to do when hyperinflation stories no longer work? https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/24/is-john-cochranes-the-banks-just-swapped-treasuries-for-reserves-qe-was-mostly-inert-narrative-a-little-glib-do-right-wingers-confuse-financial-intermediaries-with/

Why does Noah frame Scott in these terms? (Bonnie Carr) https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/02/23/mr-smith-and-the-cruel-mandate/

Lorenzo says what needs to be said...http://skepticlawyer.com.au/2015/02/21/the-nazism-of-our-time/

Koichi Hamada wants to know, Why is Monetary Policy Underrated?
Mike Darda also focuses on Japan

Monday, February 23, 2015

Human Capital Needs a Time Based Marketplace

When intelligent people such as Branko Milanovic begin to demean human capital, I can't help but get nervous at the implications. If not for the capacity of the human mind...what, exactly?? When too many among the supply side have given up on human capital and economic potential, is this also true of the left?

Since lately it's come down to trashing human capital or or reasoning about inherent IQ and innate ability, perhaps so. Whatever happened to the wealth generating capacity of society as a whole? How can anyone possibly feel comfortable, allowing a mass experiment of mental capacity separation, to continue indefinitely? This isn't just a mass division of mental capacity playing out. It's also a vast divide which destroys the possibility of productive family formation, for the "losers".

The potential of human capital is what still gives us hope, given the present long term growth dilemma. Had it not been for an ability to reason and work with resource opportunities, I'd still be at the basic level of the animal creatures, whose environment I share (and there's a pair of wrens I wish had enough sense not to build a nest on the garage wall next to this office...). Without the combined societal benefits of countless minds before my lifetime, I probably wouldn't have had the opportunity to live 60 years already - in spite of numerous setbacks.

An ability to utilize human capital effectively isn't just about money - it's about whether we find means to make the best of our allotted time on earth. It is about getting the chance to interact effectively with people and resources in one's midst. A new marketplace for time use coordination could - over the long run - provide hope that life not become (once again) nasty, brutish and short. Even though individual time is limited, human ingenuity - as Julian Simon noted - holds infinite capacity. In spite of the fact populations haven't always gained from human ingenuity of late, the accumulated effects of earlier gains are still immense. Peter Gordon says of Julian Simon:
Whereas economists love to talk about scarce resources, it was Simon who described how one resource, human ingenuity, is not scarce; it is infinite--in a context of economic freedom
How to approach a rationale from the left that capital belongs to capitalists...yet not to people? James Pethokoukis was the recipient of one of these odd attacks recently, and he addresses it in this reasonable post. I was glad he noted Robert Reich as a proponent of human capital, something I'd almost forgotten after reading Reich's very good book, "The Work Of Nations", in the early nineties. Unfortunately, human capital has gradually become associated with the money and connections it often takes to have one's voice heard - which could have some bearing why it is now being exposed to ridicule.

In a compensated marketplace for time use, the point would not be to generate "perfect" skills product. After all, is there even such a thing? Time use - particularly for education and healthcare - is highly experiential in nature. Not having to assign specific value to specific knowledge in these settings, would make its use more flexible for the purpose of any given moment. Plus, a time based marketplace would provide means - and reasons - for individuals to seek one another out, once again. This is particularly important, given the fact that mass production and technology has meant that many have forgotten the reasons they once came together. A lack of reasoning for coming together in shared economic purpose, is particularly what leaves populations exposed to extremes such as these.

What's more, it is better to monetarily compensate individuals for helping one another, than to compensate them as a consolation prize for being "left out", especially as a long term monetary strategy. The existence of a linked and constant time continuum, means that groups would be able to contribute to societal gains which would gradually build on the initial exploratory efforts of these systems.

Knowledge use has the capacity to carry across a broader spectrum of economic activity, than is presently the case. It can be utilized in far more ways, than is possible within the compensated time use realm which single institutions employ. Knowledge is the component of human capital which has the capacity to transcend time, provided it remains embedded in a continuous time use context. The embedding of knowledge use in present day institutions is not continuous, because it serves the purpose of specific missions and profit goals, rather than the purposes of a given public at large.

However, a time based marketplace with multiple purpose coordination, would provide greater stability for knowledge use preservation. Paul Krugman recently wrote, "Knowledge isn't power." If it seems that knowledge isn't power, it is only because single mission environments make it difficult for individuals to make use of knowledge gains. Knowledge needs environments in which it is able to circulate freely and adapt to multiple purposes. A marketplace for time would give new economic freedom to knowledge, and in the process, allow knowledge to express the power it still holds.

Update: One way to think about the failure in monetary policy which led to the Great Recession is as a coordination failure - a thought which occurred to me after reading a Scientific American article about coordination problems. Even though it appears central bankers are (now) following a trajectory that honors aggregate spending capacity, the fact they remain unconvinced re human capital value, might explain why they stay well below the 2% inflation target, no matter the oil price. The fact that political factions on the left and right downplay human capital representation, appears part of the reason why the zero bound continues to threaten with a monetary policy which now tends deflationary. As mentioned in the linked article, groups don't always decide that it is in their best interests to take action to protect the whole group.

Saturday, February 21, 2015

The Austerity That (Ultimately) Threatens the U.S.

I cannot speak to the austerity conditions which continue to thwart Greece, for I simply don't know the nature of their services organization in relation to other parts of the economy. However, the long run austerity threat for the U.S. is easier to ascertain, in part due to the unique patterns of a services structure developed after WWII. As a result, long term budgetary concerns could possibly be more pronounced, than some countries which developed nationalized healthcare systems.

How so? Private industries which have evolved around healthcare, are heavily subsidized in ways that are mostly hidden to the public. Not only have healthcare costs become difficult to discern in real time, artificial limitations also involve the most basic surgical procedures and the right to prescribe medication. Around these limitations, immense and costly complexities have arisen - each layer of which was "supposed" to provide solutions to the core issue of artificial scarcity.

Among these layers of complexity, arguments are growing as to who even "deserves" healthcare. Even though some discussions about the "undeserving obese" have occurred in the UK, one can easily imagine a similar rationale here. It is quite a shame that some skills sets were made so sacrosanct, that they now contribute to unnecessary problems in multiple settings. Most people are far more rational than I, because they dare not point the finger at the real source of the problem, for fear of upsetting healthcare professionals among their own peers and kin. I only do so now, because it's almost as if every person alive has become "undeserving" of valuable services!

At the very least, it took a long time for the artificial scarcity of skills restrictions to affect the overall growth trajectories of nations. But that's small comfort now. And yet even though it should be obvious what happened, people still reason that these problems can be overcome without more contribution to supply. Possibly because so many forms of product exist in abundance, the same is assumed of time based services. But what if supply isn't really widespread, meaning a primary product shortage contributes to a low growth equilibrium? Nick Rowe rightly calls supply capacity into question, in a recent post where he writes:
If the apple producer wants to buy ten bananas, but the banana producer only wants to sell six bananas, then only six bananas get sold.
Why would a banana producer only want to sell 6 bananas, if they could easily produce more? Imagine a banana producer in a two product primary equilibrium, who reasons: if I can make my product important enough that it commands ten apples for 6 bananas, then why shouldn't I price, based on those terms?

For a long time the services supply asymmetry wasn't so obvious. Indeed, insurance and government requirements made the problem manageable for decades. What's more, production allocation asymmetries aren't ordinarily problematic in the marketplace if they don't represent core consumption. Just because everyone seemingly has a smart phone - for instance - does not mean the person without one is likely to be at any real disadvantage.

Artificial services scarcity might not be so obvious now, were it not for the fact a larger portion of the population anticipates health costs in the near future. Many of us who mostly avoided the doctor's office for decades, are not sure whether our good fortune will last (and for too many my age...it hasn't). This and a confluence of other factors means primary equilibrium growth is finally threatened by a six (services) banana sales total to a 10 apples (manufacture product) sales total. While some don't find this a threat in moral terms, it is nonetheless a threat in terms of growth potential.

One wonders: is this as far as the supply side argument for healthcare will ever go? If knowledge use for medication and surgery needs cannot be accessed by lower income levels, present day growth cannot be revived to its earlier trajectory. Indeed, the stubborn insistence of central bankers to remain below 2 percent inflation, makes it questionable whether the present growth trajectory can remain on an even keel. Because of the still present danger of the zero bound, future recessions could mean further production setbacks for both services and manufacture.

If the torch for economic responsibility has been passed from the supply side to the political left, the latter needs to recognize the built in growth limitations which services now hold - particularly in healthcare. In the meantime, few mention the American Medical Association as the originator of this quandary, even as virtually everyone else gets blamed for services shortfalls. Among that list but not limited to: illegal immigrants who "steal" needed services from others...poor unwed mothers...the one percenters...and baby boomers who are "stealing" the future of younger generations! As to debts which aren't going anywhere, anytime soon, consider Brad Delong's response to Diane Lim among a recent round of austerity posts. In a six point rebuttal, fortunately he thought to list healthcare first:
1) We believe that medical care is a special commodity - one that should be delivered to those who need it, not just those who can afford to pay for it out of their private means - and thus as health spending becomes a larger part of the economy the proportion of GDP spent by the government on its healthcare programs will grow.
Where to even begin, in response? Of course I agree with Brad Delong that healthcare is among the most basic of commodities. But in the U.S. it has been defined as a special product, and there is no changing that definition in the short term. Special equals exclusive, not inclusive. As a result, any access beyond what is already available will not only remain limited, future access will gradually become more constrained, if no services production reform is allowed to take place.

Fortunately, many individuals have become aware of the long term issue of healthcare as it impacts the deficit. However the reason no progress has been made, is the fact few sane individuals dare to speak to the obvious supply side restraint. This is why I suggest that physicians be allowed to train low income individuals how to heal, for knowledge use systems which will not directly compete with the existing healthcare system. Should this occur, real economic growth will once again become viable, and individuals will gain hope that they won't be completely undone by medical expenses at some point in their lifetimes.

Friday, February 20, 2015

Dreams of a More Dynamic Reality

It occurs to me that after almost two years of blogging, in spite of attempts to maintain a distinct identity, I have been pigeonholed as right wing. To a degree this is understandable because I espouse free markets and monetary solutions over fiscal solutions. I worry that governments don't understand the problems faced by those who are mostly alone in the world, and that governments force circumstance on them which convey a tremendous lack of respect for the poor and disadvantaged. However, I also question how many among the supply side dream of better economic realities, even as I wonder whether it's possible for governments to do so.

Therefore, I don't "fit in" with political right categorizations as easily as one might think. It's been almost six years since I first became acquainted with online blogging, and in that time I've managed to become a bit of a nuisance to all concerned. Still, I need to do a better job of communicating on left leaning blog sites, and hopefully I can do so without being so confrontational in the future.

In spite of my desire to remain non ideological, identity and affiliation are of course inevitable. That also holds true for economists as a group, along with the messages economists convey to laypeople such as myself. While some online participants have moved on to other activities, there's still plenty to glean from the discussions that remain. Might all this outpouring of online energy, eventually translate into new local economic energy and dynamism?

Alas, not yet. The blogosphere appeared to shift about a year earlier, once monetary policy at the Fed began to move towards a "normalization" position. Was a torch being passed to the left? In retrospect...perhaps, for it would have been difficult to imagine Washington speaking of a general economic slowdown, had they not directly received this message from private enterprise. Over time, the U.S. regained some of the confidence which was lost in the worst days of the Great Recession. For all practical purposes, "victory" was being declared, in spite of protestations from market monetarists and others who were more attuned to circumstance on the ground.

One reason it was easy to declare victory was the fact Wall Street has taken the place of Main Street in many ways. After all, who really associates Main Street with macroeconomic anything?? All the dynamism one would supposedly want, could be found in the numbers, the statistics, the gains in wealth that were quite real. Hence, some right leaning blogs returned to topics more microeconomic and at times even superficial in nature. That doesn't mean everyone suddenly lost their interest in macroeconomic concerns. On the contrary. What's more: surely it's not just me noticing, that quite a few newer blogging voices lean left.

Sometimes the rhetoric gets so caught up in technical concerns that it's difficult to find the connections to reality. How can economies become more inclusive, in growth based terms? The problem I have with the present fiscal/monetary debate, is a lack of clarity. After all, the inclusion of the forgotten is where real growth and stabilization is possible, yet this fact just gets demolished in the constant static of middle class fears. It is the lower classes which - given the chance to prosper - could help the middle classes - not the more limited local participation of the upper classes. In particular, any discussion of infrastructure desperately needs better context, just as regulatory discussion needs specific and understandable context. Just as the supply side never delivered the more dynamic marketplace I dreamed of, it's hard to see how roads and bridges infrastructure is going to hire or make a future, for the millions of compromised individuals no one notices anymore.

What's really at stake in all this? When I advocate for human capital, I do so based on potential self worth, not the arbitrary worth that is assigned to individuals by institutions. Are capitalists any different from countless other power mongers? Of course not. The faux problem of capitalist "aggression" is hardly the reality of most individuals who simply want a chance to use their mind to better their lives and surroundings. The power mongers to worry about are those who use legal means to keep individuals from freely sharing their skills with others. When this occurs, all the petty power mongers then emerge, to take advantage of those who were denied the economic means to support themselves. The best way to defend human capital, is to defend it at the core, before it gets exposed to more belittlement than necessary.*

Human capital is the original economic reality, of which capitalism is but a late derivative. It holds a vital link with time - in spite of the negative labor/time association stressed by Branko Milanovic. Say what one will about time - it defines our existence for better or worse. Don't get me wrong, for I understand the capital minus time argument he posed in the above link. Still, I have to ask: if we lose the experiential element of the time component, what else do we have?

Time is the part of our reality which matters most. Whereas if human capital doesn't matter, time use doesn't matter and the automation which frees our time to live life as we desire, doesn't matter. Do we really want automation to completely assume the negotiation capacity and experiential aspects of our time based position? Should anyone remain convinced (!) that the human capital concept is demeaning, time value could be lost and we are uncomfortably close to losing it as it is. Should human capital be claimed for the importance it holds in a marketplace for time, automation would augment our lives and abilities - not the other way around.

Thus far, growth since the Great Recession has mostly taken place on exclusive terms. In other words, gains continue to be made on the part of intact families among the middle class. Even though these gains are not presently showing up in income, they show up for instance in the still considerable monetary flows between housing wealth and education at local levels, such as the walking path in a pecan grove near my neighborhood which was recently leveled to create new baseball and softball fields. Near term future wealth will likely continue to take place along these lines. While these fiscal improvements have real value, they do little to address relatively deserted Main Streets or the fact that marginalized citizens still seek means to participate in the marketplace and public areas.

The means to participate with others for the full course of a lifetime, is the human capital I want back. That's the economic dynamism I still dream about: tiny capillaries of Main Streets everywhere that can keep entire economic bodies vital and alive. Reciprocal monetary flows, which allow people from all walks of life to have reason to interact with the world in their midst.

When I think how some are convinced that human capital is demeaning, I cry inside - indeed that is why this post has gone "over the top" sensitive and a bit shy of logical. When people give up on one another as in the present, they give up on immigration as well. As to the robots, one could say they have already surpassed us if we insist on competing on their turf. Do we still believe in the integrity of experiential product? Do we still believe in the value of our time, and the time of others? We are the only ones that can provide those answers and meaningfully act on them. No product has to be "perfect" - whatever that is - and neither does the time we choose to share.

Most people, given the chance, don't want the handout of a condescending transfer payment - a non solution so poorly thought through it is not even a valid component of GDP. All too often, a transfer payment reminds someone they've arrived on what can be a really scary dead end street, where no one really knows or cares what happens to them. Most individuals try their best to remain a part of the world around them, as long as they are still able to get out of bed in the morning. There's nothing wrong with professional offices and big box retail holding valuable real estate on well traveled roads and the public places we hold in common. But there still needs to be plenty of room on these public byways for everyone else to participate and find positive experience as well. That is the message too many people of every political inclination thus far, have missed.

*Update: Here's a good example, how it is best to protect human capital "at the core", i.e. make certain that consumption definitions remain flexible and amenable to potential innovation. A post from Nick Bunker suggests the supply side remedy of "reforming  finance" so as to make the economy more productive. However, his reasoning is backwards. When individuals are free to utilize human capital to improve their surroundings, they need less financial assistance in all areas of their life.

Thursday, February 19, 2015

Time Aggregates and Growth Potential

While there are means to maintain growth, reducing time aggregate representation in the marketplace is not one of them. Governments and central bankers are playing with fire, when they tolerate policies which ultimately lead to fewer hours worked. Indeed, the recent decline in oil prices provided a perfect cover (cheap gas is great for the consumer? hmm), for the fact that deflation is being actively encouraged, to lower aggregate spending capacity.

Even though the U.S. has experienced supply side growth from oil production, "total petroleum consumption is down 21% from its 2005 peak". This, in a time when populations continue to grow, and more economists are becoming aware that growth cannot simply occur on consumption based terms. How might nations be encouraged to once again include their citizens in vital production and services roles?

Production of the future needs to be approached differently, because time also holds value as a primary product - not just product input. Consumption decisions also depend on the paths utilized, for production potential. If citizens aren't buying gas, what does that say about their other time use choices? Lower gas consumption holds vital clues about the marketplace many individuals now desire.

Knowledge use systems would allow more concentrated organization for work and life diversity. In many instances, these systems would not require the same infrastructure associated with automobiles and related transportation. Indeed, some services oriented communities could be built around interior bicycle and walking paths for normal workday routines, and more traditional transportation structure around the perimeters for the times when local citizens seek to connect with other cities and regions.

These forms of density and diversity planning would bring many back into the workplace, who simply can't afford the terms of economic access as they are presently structured. What's more, these systems would mean a new form of growth which could prove capable of returning to a more robust growth trajectory. This is particularly important because deficient demand is slowly leading to its own deflationary spiral. As to persistent below target inflation, Simon Wren-Lewis says:
You do not sit back, tell yourself that below target inflation is probably temporary, and do nothing. And of course, you do not plan for more fiscal austerity.
There are two things about his sentiment worthy of note. First, fiscal austerity is having more difficulty getting at the root of the problem, than monetary policy. Also, because non profit and for profit endeavor follow similar guidelines, the real monetary/fiscal problem is a lack of organizational capacity to generate new growth potential. Fiscal policy has become a catch all phrase in a world which can now scarcely distinguish between governmental and private activity.

The main thing that can be determined from these circumstance is that time participation is still dying on the vine, as various camps argue over the particulars of economic stability.  A discussion between W. Peden and Wren-Lewis in the above linked post, touched on the importance of ascertaining a reasonable level, when the output gap is considered. W. Peden also noted the fact that time aggregates or hours worked, may be more important than unemployment levels.

One thing that concerned Wren-Lewis, was the difficulty of maintaining both productivity and measurement capacity for the self employed. This is something that a knowledge use system would be able to address in a number of ways. In a coordinated time use marketplace, the self employed would have more takers for the skills sets they offer, and they would have better luck with their offerings than if they had to fight for a limited market share in primary equilibrium. As a former piano teacher trying to find and maintain students outside of regular school systems...just trust me on this one. It would be quite a difference, if only in attitude towards community members as to the skills they could share.

Another benefit is that time matching would take place within close time frames and recorded at the outset. There would be no need to wait for end of the year tax returns to ascertain the work activity and income of the self employed. Granted, hourly income in time arbitrage would be of a more limited nature than income in primary equilibrium. Still, ongoing local investments could also be recorded on an ongoing basis within the participating groups, so that real time monetary measurement for local economic activity would remain possible.

A primary benefit for knowledge use systems is that they could gradually bring time aggregates in the U.S. back to their recent levels of labor participation. With a little luck, the fiscal/monetary battle can die down as it becomes more apparent that what is needed is real change in organizational capacity, so that the paths to growth do not continue to be blocked at every turn.