Will rates go back to zero in the next recession...or before? (Scott Sumner) The Phillips Curve and interest rate targeting are dead. What next?
Why doesn't the model work well in this instance? The musical chairs model in the UK
Britmouse responds: Musical chairs in Britain, Revisited
The bond market suffered in 1994: Do central banks worry more about the bond market or the labor market? Bill Woolsey responds: What do central bankers want?
Core PCE level targeting is better than (the current) PCE inflation targeting: Reducing Fed discretion (dedicated to John Taylor)
Scott finds seven (!) ways to "repair" a Robert Waldmann post: Let me know when critics respond to our actual ideas
Explaining a nominal target at a press conference would be less bother: Making life easier for central bankers
Austerity cannot be helped, if there is no help for monetary growth: Obama's horrible advice to Germany
Econlog posts from Scott:
The Wittgenstein test
Have an opinion about string theory? How about macroeconomics?
A response from Noah Smith - Why do non-experts think they know about macroeconomics?
If government has little pressure to do the right thing...Reasoning from a price change, example #341
"We just saw it from a different point of view" "Tangled up" in identities:
CAUTION Accounting Identity Handle With Care (David Glasner)
There's no point in arguing over definitions (Scott Sumner)
Sumner and Glasner on Identities (Bill Woolsey)
Savings and Investment Aren't the Same Thing and There's No Good Reason to Define Them As Such (David Glasner)
More Basic Macro (Bill Woolsey)
...but will this change the (fiscal) conversation? (Britmouse) https://uneconomical.wordpress.com/2015/02/13/bank-of-england-no-longer-at-the-zlb/
Too many similarities to the 1930s (Lars Christensen) http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/13/now-the-enriched-country-merely-declares-it-is-insolvent-and-spits-on-its-victims/
Things are improving at least for monetary policy...http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/16/mikio-kumada-tells-the-right-story-about-the-japanese-gdp-numbers/
Will monetary policy become more expansionary? (Marcus Nunes) https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/12/sweden-the-sins-of-the-father/
His voice has become somewhat muted: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/12/et-tu-carney/
Some board members take monetary policy very personally... https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/12/tight-monetary-policy-can-be-truly-deadly/
"extreme accomodation" it wasn't: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/13/7-years-crying-wolf/
NAIRU does not make sense: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/14/why-insist-on-searching-for-the-holy-grail-aka-nairu/
Marcus illustrates the difference between the two: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/16/there-was-no-first-great-depression-just-the-great-depression/
1981 versus 2007 in graphs: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/16/contrasting-recoveries-from-an-mm-perspective-an-alternative-to-john-taylors-machine/
Overlapping generations and further literature from Roger Farmer (Nick Rowe) http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/teaching-olg-models-and-the-phenomenology-of-perception.html
Nick debates a bit of (Piketty inspired) nonsense: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/human-capital-and-land-capital.html
Of governments and banana machines... http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/do-economically-illiterate-slobs-use-duality-theory.html
Benjamin Cole has some fun with Cochrane's "econo-judo": https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/14/my-blog-u-ment-with-john-cochrane-or-et-tu-ken-duda/
This is particularly surprising for those of us who remember Japan's heyday: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/16/john-cochrane-dream-vs-reality-in-the-far-east/
Politicized well past the point of being effective...(Bonnie Carr) https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/02/13/interest-rate-quandary-sooner-rather-than-later-or-let-sleeping-dogs-lie/
Wednesday, February 18, 2015
Tuesday, February 17, 2015
Supply Side...Perhaps "Direct Side" Economics?
Looking through a series of Wikipedia economic entries, I happened on the entry for supply-side and found the emphasis interesting. Here's how it begins:
As to tax rate changes, they serve as a fallback method not just for business interests, but for everyone else as well. Economic progress? Hmm, depends on which party is in power and how one feels about the party. In all of this, actual structural issues tend to be swept aside, and the initial impetus to provide economic access gets lost. Perhaps this is why some supply side efforts are disregarded as trickle-down economics.
When discussions turn to inequality, a partially broken or missing marketplace makes it difficult to determine any reasonable course of action. Governments can't provide something that may not even exist - particularly services. In what sense are service related supply side factors "responsible" for inequality? It depends. Hence, even though it's obvious where some price rigidities reside - such as rising prices for cancer drugs - where does one even begin? A high tax on the profits of successful pharmaceuticals is not going to solve the medical access or production problems they have created for everyone else - businesses included.
Nor is a low tax on their profits likely to encourage them to lower prices or hire more researchers. It's painful for me to witness media accounts of people making walks across the country (or related efforts) to raise money for research into cures. How many precious research hours will those hard won dollars actually provide? The way these institutions have specialized time value, the (traditional economic) value of time such as my own - similar to that of many people around the globe - would hardly represent a drop in their valuable bucket. And yet for centuries, research was performed because people wanted the challenge and scarcely gave a second thought to the time involved, not because a few isolated individuals were christened with the special privilege of healing, on the "supposed" behalf of taxpayers and everyone else. What kind of rationale is that?
Step back for a moment and consider where today's pharmaceuticals gained their protected position in society. They were able to do so in large part because of the already existing prestige of physicians associations. As a result, pharmaceutical companies were also able to slowly wear away at the ability of local environments to produce and partake in countless means for healing, until healing at low income levels and in rural regions has become practically nonexistent in the U.S.
However, the reason they gained this competitive advantage in the first place was the fact that the service formation of physicians - over time - had gained the status of a superior good. While in a sense there is nothing wrong with such status - given the years required for the education and intense commitments required for doctors, the problem is that the marketplace was effectively removed for everyone else. Yet governments have been foolhardy enough to insist on somehow apportioning to all, the generous rewards of extreme artificial time use scarcity. Good luck with that.
This removal of the alternative marketplace is so thoroughly entrenched, that it continues to threaten what remnants still exist. When the media recently warned of of an altered substance in some herbal capsule formulations, the warning came along with an admonition to never rely on herbal remedies in the first place! And my alternative as a low income consumer - other than the far more limited realm of over the counter drugs is - ??? I've never received a warning from the media to cease and desist taking (the constantly TV advertised) prescription drugs as a general rule, should any of these companies be foolish enough to tamper with their own product. And in several instances over the years, I've not come across either prescriptions or OTC medication which take the approach I actually need.
Circumstance such as these are why it is difficult to overcome the complete takeover in the marketplace, by what is now considered traditional medicine. However, the fact this has occurred holds considerable responsibility for the worst inequality and economic access issues in the services marketplace. Most important is that - particularly in an age of growing automation and concern about employment prospects for the future - it has become dangerous to assume all services work can be assigned either superior good status or else leftover "dregs for dummies".
To be sure, the law of one price is problematic in this regard. People in the U.S. who can afford to do so, travel to other countries to access affordable (i.e. "differently" priced) medicine, instead of expecting to find it somewhere at home. It's often not reasonable to expect pricing differentiation for services product, locally. Why? Unlike more obvious quality indicators of tradable goods, time based "cheaper" service variants call expensive time based variants into question. How does one know what is actually different?
The fact that knowledge use systems would work completely differently (through coordinated time arbitrage) is precisely what allows them to sidestep the law of one price problem. Fortunately, consumers tend to be more forgiving about pricing in other non tradable good formations. For instance, it's not difficult to understand differences in land valuation and the non tradable good of buildings. The geographic component makes it easier to understand differences in price for these.
At the very least, a marketplace for time would mean the possibility of services on normal and not just "superior" terms. The worst thing about services as designated "special" good for middle upper and upper income? In spite of the time scarcity everyone holds in an individual sense, overall time aggregates are grossly shorted in value, which creates asymmetries everywhere one looks. A marketplace for time use would "right" many wrongs in terms of services exclusion, in places where it is needed most.
Knowledge use systems would in effect be a "direct side" approach, to much needed marketplace formation. Any time that societies reach a point where immigration is discouraged and eugenic references creep back into any national dialog, it becomes clear that more than taxation and political strategies are needed. Knowledge use systems would also be able to maintain information and time use structures digitally, so that new methodology can be shared with others who seek to establish knowledge use systems as well.
It's not that commonly used knowledge couldn't be available for all. However, the inability of either government or existing businesses to supply adequate knowledge use and services, needs to be addressed. Increasingly, large swathes of existing knowledge and underutilized humanity need to be tapped, to narrow what has become a growing intelligence use gap, between the rich and the poor.
Supply-side economics is a school of macroeconomics that argues that economic growth can be most effectively created by lowering barriers for people to produce (supply) goods and services as well as invest in capital. According to supply-side economics, consumers will then benefit from a greater supply of goods and services at lower prices: furthermore, the investment and expansion of business will increase the demand for employees.Sounds reasonably promising thus far...right? Except the means for this encouraging quote mostly comes down to:
Typical policy recommendations of supply-side economists are lower marginal tax rates and less regulation.Aah, less regulation: the ever desirable situation which seldom translates into realities for greater economic access. Readers are already aware of my dubious response to ongoing tax shuffles - political and legal stalemates are "made of this". At first glance, the Wikipedia quote appears to address some of the structural issues alluded to in yesterday's post. But...regulation changes for who? Do those changes seek to create a pathway, or obstruct existing pathways? In other words, what are regulation specs intended to accomplish, and is that obvious to everyone involved? Do more individuals gain the chance to participate, or less?
As to tax rate changes, they serve as a fallback method not just for business interests, but for everyone else as well. Economic progress? Hmm, depends on which party is in power and how one feels about the party. In all of this, actual structural issues tend to be swept aside, and the initial impetus to provide economic access gets lost. Perhaps this is why some supply side efforts are disregarded as trickle-down economics.
When discussions turn to inequality, a partially broken or missing marketplace makes it difficult to determine any reasonable course of action. Governments can't provide something that may not even exist - particularly services. In what sense are service related supply side factors "responsible" for inequality? It depends. Hence, even though it's obvious where some price rigidities reside - such as rising prices for cancer drugs - where does one even begin? A high tax on the profits of successful pharmaceuticals is not going to solve the medical access or production problems they have created for everyone else - businesses included.
Nor is a low tax on their profits likely to encourage them to lower prices or hire more researchers. It's painful for me to witness media accounts of people making walks across the country (or related efforts) to raise money for research into cures. How many precious research hours will those hard won dollars actually provide? The way these institutions have specialized time value, the (traditional economic) value of time such as my own - similar to that of many people around the globe - would hardly represent a drop in their valuable bucket. And yet for centuries, research was performed because people wanted the challenge and scarcely gave a second thought to the time involved, not because a few isolated individuals were christened with the special privilege of healing, on the "supposed" behalf of taxpayers and everyone else. What kind of rationale is that?
Step back for a moment and consider where today's pharmaceuticals gained their protected position in society. They were able to do so in large part because of the already existing prestige of physicians associations. As a result, pharmaceutical companies were also able to slowly wear away at the ability of local environments to produce and partake in countless means for healing, until healing at low income levels and in rural regions has become practically nonexistent in the U.S.
However, the reason they gained this competitive advantage in the first place was the fact that the service formation of physicians - over time - had gained the status of a superior good. While in a sense there is nothing wrong with such status - given the years required for the education and intense commitments required for doctors, the problem is that the marketplace was effectively removed for everyone else. Yet governments have been foolhardy enough to insist on somehow apportioning to all, the generous rewards of extreme artificial time use scarcity. Good luck with that.
This removal of the alternative marketplace is so thoroughly entrenched, that it continues to threaten what remnants still exist. When the media recently warned of of an altered substance in some herbal capsule formulations, the warning came along with an admonition to never rely on herbal remedies in the first place! And my alternative as a low income consumer - other than the far more limited realm of over the counter drugs is - ??? I've never received a warning from the media to cease and desist taking (the constantly TV advertised) prescription drugs as a general rule, should any of these companies be foolish enough to tamper with their own product. And in several instances over the years, I've not come across either prescriptions or OTC medication which take the approach I actually need.
Circumstance such as these are why it is difficult to overcome the complete takeover in the marketplace, by what is now considered traditional medicine. However, the fact this has occurred holds considerable responsibility for the worst inequality and economic access issues in the services marketplace. Most important is that - particularly in an age of growing automation and concern about employment prospects for the future - it has become dangerous to assume all services work can be assigned either superior good status or else leftover "dregs for dummies".
To be sure, the law of one price is problematic in this regard. People in the U.S. who can afford to do so, travel to other countries to access affordable (i.e. "differently" priced) medicine, instead of expecting to find it somewhere at home. It's often not reasonable to expect pricing differentiation for services product, locally. Why? Unlike more obvious quality indicators of tradable goods, time based "cheaper" service variants call expensive time based variants into question. How does one know what is actually different?
The fact that knowledge use systems would work completely differently (through coordinated time arbitrage) is precisely what allows them to sidestep the law of one price problem. Fortunately, consumers tend to be more forgiving about pricing in other non tradable good formations. For instance, it's not difficult to understand differences in land valuation and the non tradable good of buildings. The geographic component makes it easier to understand differences in price for these.
At the very least, a marketplace for time would mean the possibility of services on normal and not just "superior" terms. The worst thing about services as designated "special" good for middle upper and upper income? In spite of the time scarcity everyone holds in an individual sense, overall time aggregates are grossly shorted in value, which creates asymmetries everywhere one looks. A marketplace for time use would "right" many wrongs in terms of services exclusion, in places where it is needed most.
Knowledge use systems would in effect be a "direct side" approach, to much needed marketplace formation. Any time that societies reach a point where immigration is discouraged and eugenic references creep back into any national dialog, it becomes clear that more than taxation and political strategies are needed. Knowledge use systems would also be able to maintain information and time use structures digitally, so that new methodology can be shared with others who seek to establish knowledge use systems as well.
It's not that commonly used knowledge couldn't be available for all. However, the inability of either government or existing businesses to supply adequate knowledge use and services, needs to be addressed. Increasingly, large swathes of existing knowledge and underutilized humanity need to be tapped, to narrow what has become a growing intelligence use gap, between the rich and the poor.
Monday, February 16, 2015
What Do We Want From Our Environments?
Generally, if this question gets asked at all, it tends to be in single issue formats. Countless groups stand at the ready, to assist a specific circumstance or need. Everyone it seems, is ready to find a way to "bend" the environment to their demands. And yet nothing about life exists as a single problem to be solved. Why not a more comprehensive and integrated approach - a multitude of possibility?
In the meantime, governments have attempted to continue 21st century progress on the outdated expectations of the 20th. One of the more obvious flaws in this non strategy is "sluggish" investment. How can anyone get excited about investing, with so little certainty what anyone wants? Low interest rates are a significant part of this scenario, but some remain confused by low interest rates just the same. Doesn't that indicate a good time for governments to borrow? Not necessarily so, as Scott Sumner notes once again.
Even though monetary conditions are better, the structural debate for long term strategies has scarcely begun. Indeed, some are convinced what passes for discussion in this regard is mostly handwaving. For instance, as Lars Christensen notes about Japan's somewhat improved scenario:
There are still investments which governments could make on behalf of their citizens. However the opportune moment for any government to make new commitments, is when its citizens are already inspired to do the same. The fact that no one is making any substantial first moves, suggests it is time to figure out what people want from their lives and and their circumstance. While the answers of course will differ, there are nonetheless patterns that can be distinguished in the dialogue.
For one thing, changes - particularly those involving infrastructure - can't just be imposed on already existing environments. While some adaptation can take place (i.e. density adjustments for instance), it's best not to expect too much for regions which have long since matured into unique identities. Instead, governments and citizens need to look for economic potential either in adjacent or even entirely new locations. Rather than committing to expensive infrastructure at the outset, groups can experiment with flexible infrastructure and working arrangements, to see where new production and services formation may take hold. In some instances, individuals who wish to take part may be able to lend time and skills commitments, particularly when they don't have sufficient monetary resources at the outset.
Domestic summits can assist in what would become a gradual matching process: one that would allow citizens to come together for similar strategies in production and services structure. In a sense these environments would give new meaning to entrepreneurial activity. After all, it is possible to think of individuals "hiring" one another for time arbitrage. What's more, some would experience a revival of almost forgotten social skill sets. Newly formed communities would gradually lead to other shared investment strategies, in their turn.
Often, people with varying abilities and income levels need different forms of infrastructure as well. Having life/work choices such as this could mean not needing to claim disability or - for some baby boomers - a way to avoid having to take early social security compensation. For too many, the biggest difficulty is trying to work at the high level of expectation, inherent in many settings. Far better, to generate communities which match aptitudes and goal sets more closely. Far better, to make certain everyone has ways to remain responsible and connected to others.
In the meantime, governments have attempted to continue 21st century progress on the outdated expectations of the 20th. One of the more obvious flaws in this non strategy is "sluggish" investment. How can anyone get excited about investing, with so little certainty what anyone wants? Low interest rates are a significant part of this scenario, but some remain confused by low interest rates just the same. Doesn't that indicate a good time for governments to borrow? Not necessarily so, as Scott Sumner notes once again.
Even though monetary conditions are better, the structural debate for long term strategies has scarcely begun. Indeed, some are convinced what passes for discussion in this regard is mostly handwaving. For instance, as Lars Christensen notes about Japan's somewhat improved scenario:
Now Prime Minister Abe has to deliver on structural reform, but that can be said about every industrialized country in the world.Oddly, when countries are slow to consider the needs and circumstance of their own citizens, domestic concerns end up overshadowed by changing world events. It's a pattern which repeats all too often. Why should war have to be the factor that finally mobilizes populations?
There are still investments which governments could make on behalf of their citizens. However the opportune moment for any government to make new commitments, is when its citizens are already inspired to do the same. The fact that no one is making any substantial first moves, suggests it is time to figure out what people want from their lives and and their circumstance. While the answers of course will differ, there are nonetheless patterns that can be distinguished in the dialogue.
For one thing, changes - particularly those involving infrastructure - can't just be imposed on already existing environments. While some adaptation can take place (i.e. density adjustments for instance), it's best not to expect too much for regions which have long since matured into unique identities. Instead, governments and citizens need to look for economic potential either in adjacent or even entirely new locations. Rather than committing to expensive infrastructure at the outset, groups can experiment with flexible infrastructure and working arrangements, to see where new production and services formation may take hold. In some instances, individuals who wish to take part may be able to lend time and skills commitments, particularly when they don't have sufficient monetary resources at the outset.
Domestic summits can assist in what would become a gradual matching process: one that would allow citizens to come together for similar strategies in production and services structure. In a sense these environments would give new meaning to entrepreneurial activity. After all, it is possible to think of individuals "hiring" one another for time arbitrage. What's more, some would experience a revival of almost forgotten social skill sets. Newly formed communities would gradually lead to other shared investment strategies, in their turn.
Sunday, February 15, 2015
Human Capital Also Holds Value In Use
Why is this important? Because value in exchange can at times be limited by definition, in terms of both resource potential and economic access. While many forms of scarcities have been relieved, scarcity is still problematic for both time use potential and geographic potential - i.e. the land versus human capital equivalence. This has bearing why it can be difficult to make time aggregates optimal, as a whole.
Because time product is naturally limited (finite), services coordination cannot always be accessed on value in exchange terms without distorting general equilibrium. Even so, people compensate for given scarcities however they can, through value in use means. While value in use can be helpful on a personal level, its potential could be greatly magnified through societal coordination. Value in use services formation would help to address present day imbalances, and (underutilized) human capital potential would play a primary role.
After writing yesterday's, post, I read two other posts about human capital, the first by Nick Rowe ("Human Capital" and "Land Capital") who was responding to Branco Milanovic. To be sure I was somewhat upset by the post from Milanovic, and am reminded that Piketty's recent book gives rise to these kinds of arguments. Milanovic stressed getting rid of the notion of human capital, while most readers are well aware I believe a move in the other direction is needed, instead.
Yesterday's post provided examples regarding knowledge transformation as value in use, through contractual agreement. However value in (knowledge) use needs careful delineation, from a value in exchange knowledge perspective. Many thought processes which individuals respond to, are voiced on commonly accepted value in exchange terms. That is certainly the perspective one finds in Nick Rowe's post.
His land examples as contrast with human capital examples are particularly helpful. For one thing, land holds greater value if it is adjacent to other land which has gained in value. This dovetails nicely with human capital educational investment, which generally holds less risk in the event of family connections. Meritocratic structure of human capital and knowledge use is limited, given a lack of fiscal ability to compensate knowledge under value in exchange circumstance.
Hence when it is not possible to increase economic growth through traditional means, an understandable value in use framework is needed for knowledge use. This would make it possible for a greater percentage of any population, to work with what has become today's primary resource. How has knowledge use value surpassed land value in this regard?
Primary land value tends to be determined by its access to prosperous regions, even though land still holds value in use through small scale agriculture. A century earlier, if few other means of production existed, one could still gain value in exchange through the application of skill, time, muscle and new machinery to work the land. The problem for many was that once agricultural product became less expensive, personal effort in this regard mostly became value in use. Today, knowledge use has supplanted agriculture as the primary means of survival. Even though land associated with knowledge use systems would not gain the value of prosperous regions, it would gain value as compared to land used for agricultural purposes.
Knowledge (in human capital context) which holds additional value of exchange, can at times be devalued when it is contrast with knowledge which might undermine "conventional wisdom" in some way. However, competition of this sort is not at all the intent of any coordinated knowledge use system.
On the contrary, knowledge use simply needs a more respectable position for populations as a whole, beyond existing university systems. While it may be easy to assume that practical knowledge use applies where other knowledge is in short supply, this has not been the case, given political realities in the U.S. Political dialogue is insufficient for solving the problems of the present. If value in exchange means limited services formation, further services growth is also needed on value in use terms.
Fortunately, there are reasonable ways to distinguish whether knowledge holds value in use versus value in exchange. First, a marketplace for time is necessary, before knowledge use as practical in nature has workable context. Within value in exchange, human capital is compensated according to pricing as recognized and also coordinated by primary equilibrium. Whereas value in use is compensated through time coordination within specific groupings on equal terms. That compensation provides seed money for further investment endeavor. The difference in this perspective, provides room for knowledge use and human capital potential, which would otherwise have little room to grow
Because time product is naturally limited (finite), services coordination cannot always be accessed on value in exchange terms without distorting general equilibrium. Even so, people compensate for given scarcities however they can, through value in use means. While value in use can be helpful on a personal level, its potential could be greatly magnified through societal coordination. Value in use services formation would help to address present day imbalances, and (underutilized) human capital potential would play a primary role.
After writing yesterday's, post, I read two other posts about human capital, the first by Nick Rowe ("Human Capital" and "Land Capital") who was responding to Branco Milanovic. To be sure I was somewhat upset by the post from Milanovic, and am reminded that Piketty's recent book gives rise to these kinds of arguments. Milanovic stressed getting rid of the notion of human capital, while most readers are well aware I believe a move in the other direction is needed, instead.
Yesterday's post provided examples regarding knowledge transformation as value in use, through contractual agreement. However value in (knowledge) use needs careful delineation, from a value in exchange knowledge perspective. Many thought processes which individuals respond to, are voiced on commonly accepted value in exchange terms. That is certainly the perspective one finds in Nick Rowe's post.
His land examples as contrast with human capital examples are particularly helpful. For one thing, land holds greater value if it is adjacent to other land which has gained in value. This dovetails nicely with human capital educational investment, which generally holds less risk in the event of family connections. Meritocratic structure of human capital and knowledge use is limited, given a lack of fiscal ability to compensate knowledge under value in exchange circumstance.
Hence when it is not possible to increase economic growth through traditional means, an understandable value in use framework is needed for knowledge use. This would make it possible for a greater percentage of any population, to work with what has become today's primary resource. How has knowledge use value surpassed land value in this regard?
Primary land value tends to be determined by its access to prosperous regions, even though land still holds value in use through small scale agriculture. A century earlier, if few other means of production existed, one could still gain value in exchange through the application of skill, time, muscle and new machinery to work the land. The problem for many was that once agricultural product became less expensive, personal effort in this regard mostly became value in use. Today, knowledge use has supplanted agriculture as the primary means of survival. Even though land associated with knowledge use systems would not gain the value of prosperous regions, it would gain value as compared to land used for agricultural purposes.
Knowledge (in human capital context) which holds additional value of exchange, can at times be devalued when it is contrast with knowledge which might undermine "conventional wisdom" in some way. However, competition of this sort is not at all the intent of any coordinated knowledge use system.
On the contrary, knowledge use simply needs a more respectable position for populations as a whole, beyond existing university systems. While it may be easy to assume that practical knowledge use applies where other knowledge is in short supply, this has not been the case, given political realities in the U.S. Political dialogue is insufficient for solving the problems of the present. If value in exchange means limited services formation, further services growth is also needed on value in use terms.
Fortunately, there are reasonable ways to distinguish whether knowledge holds value in use versus value in exchange. First, a marketplace for time is necessary, before knowledge use as practical in nature has workable context. Within value in exchange, human capital is compensated according to pricing as recognized and also coordinated by primary equilibrium. Whereas value in use is compensated through time coordination within specific groupings on equal terms. That compensation provides seed money for further investment endeavor. The difference in this perspective, provides room for knowledge use and human capital potential, which would otherwise have little room to grow
Saturday, February 14, 2015
Human Capital: The Missing Anchor
For much of history, education was associated with the ability to freely impart one's experiences, observations, and personal endeavor with others - whether for practical or more intellectual challenges. Doesn't this informal - yet valuable measure of shared experience - still hold? Not necessarily. Much of life is differentiated to a point that family and neighbors hold few common experiences beyond the walls of public or private endeavor. And those walls contain but a fragment of human potential.
One might not assume a need for economic coordination on a broader scale. But the lack of shared experience has meant lost friendships and lost trust. Too often, people have little reason to communicate with one another, particularly if they don't have the pathways of economic access which make it easier to do so.
Not long ago, Tyler Cowen asked his readers for nominations as to those who should be noted for their contributions. Had I remembered soon enough I would have suggested Ivan Illich, for his thoughts about education remain as timely as ever. Illich seemed to know what was at stake. People would gradually lose important local connections, as education became more rigid and formalized. While many were able to remain social through sports activities, shopping and other shared outings, others became more isolated. Finally, even the consumer role has became difficult to fulfill. More production from everyone, please - not just the "cream of the crop". From Ian Shepherdson, when asked about the future:
How can human capital be thought about in more productive and rewarding terms? When neighbors still had common purpose, the goals of the young also mattered, for what the community was able to become. "It takes a village" (to raise a child), as Hillary Clinton wrote in the mid nineties. Even though Clinton meant well, she used the phrase for the goals of the state, rather than the goals of community. Yet even Republicans who disagree with her arguments, essentially approach education by the same means. While Clinton's book inspired many, it played a role in creating a preschool learning environment which only moved the needle of time value further away, from the limited time value everyone still held.
Children need new ways to be responsible long before they reach adulthood, and they need to be monetarily compensated for doing so. Even if they do not remain in the community of their childhood for a lifetime, they will have gained more meaningful friendships than otherwise would have been possible, by helping others. One of the best things about local investment is that it can be augmented by purposeful time choice. In knowledge use systems, these individuals will have already spent their younger years assisting their own classmates in their studies and ongoing work projects. What's more, access to local community investments from an early age, makes it possible to pursue other goals and challenges when one is ready to do so.
Human capital needs to remain closely associated with the income streams that individuals rely on, on a regular basis. The time value that friends still seek where possible, can become the compensated time value which local residents ultimately discover. As Dr. Madsen Pirie wrote recently, it is economic "nonsense" to assume that there needs to be a winner in every bargain. This holds particularly true for time arbitrage which holds both economic and social value. Investment capacity has been lost, because everyone has forgotten how time value actually exists in relation to resource value. As a result, the purpose of education has blurred considerably.
Just as private enterprise came to share responsibility for healthcare expenses in the U.S., public education relied on housing capital held by individuals (property taxation) to achieve its goals. One could say housing capital remains "parked" in local economies primarily for education expenses which outweigh those of other public service expenses. However, housing capital can be freed from providing educational income streams, so that people could be tapped directly for matched educational income streams. The direct link that once existed between human capital and educational potential, needs to be repaired.
Washington's subsidized support for housing, is the primary link national government now holds with local economies - large and small. Consequently this provides support for today's K-12 educational structures as well. Each Washington supported "bigger and better" house became bigger and better salaries for teachers in recent decades. Indeed, there was never an effective taxation system such as this for healthcare, in terms of local government budgets. As a result, local wealth didn't translate into local healthcare needs. This is one of the main reasons time value needs to become a serious option for healthcare needs, because many still can't afford healthcare in spite of its support from government and countless non profits.
Not only does human capital need to be more widely supported in community, housing as wealth needs to become a more flexible part of the equation. Stair step knowledge use could be a "pass it forward" learning method, by which students are compensated for passing on their core studies to the next younger group. This process would allow full utilization of human capital at every step of the process, in ways that generate much needed monetary flows in local economies.
In earlier societies, education often took place through an ongoing time use continuum. Not only does this natural process smooth consumption roles for multiple generations, it would also apply for a similar strategy in building component and land use investment. There is much potential wealth to be captured in the investment process of learning, which until now has been largely wasted in terms of personal identity and economic capacity. The incremental process of learning, pairs quite well with the incremental process of investment activity as one goes through life. By no means should these activities be reserved for only a small portion of humanity, when it is possible for anyone of limited means to grow a better future through a much needed, value in use economy.
Update - Nick Rowe has a good post today about human capital, as well:
http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/human-capital-and-land-capital.html
One might not assume a need for economic coordination on a broader scale. But the lack of shared experience has meant lost friendships and lost trust. Too often, people have little reason to communicate with one another, particularly if they don't have the pathways of economic access which make it easier to do so.
Not long ago, Tyler Cowen asked his readers for nominations as to those who should be noted for their contributions. Had I remembered soon enough I would have suggested Ivan Illich, for his thoughts about education remain as timely as ever. Illich seemed to know what was at stake. People would gradually lose important local connections, as education became more rigid and formalized. While many were able to remain social through sports activities, shopping and other shared outings, others became more isolated. Finally, even the consumer role has became difficult to fulfill. More production from everyone, please - not just the "cream of the crop". From Ian Shepherdson, when asked about the future:
We can't have the economy driven just by the consumer. We need capital spending to provide a boost to productivity.But what about the capital that individuals have already invested in themselves? Without a marketplace specifically delineated for time use, that effort can be lost. Plus, many of the simpler investments and resources available to those with lower income levels, don't always provide reliable income streams in the present. This can be problematic if one needs to rely on self employment that does not involve continuous physical labor.
How can human capital be thought about in more productive and rewarding terms? When neighbors still had common purpose, the goals of the young also mattered, for what the community was able to become. "It takes a village" (to raise a child), as Hillary Clinton wrote in the mid nineties. Even though Clinton meant well, she used the phrase for the goals of the state, rather than the goals of community. Yet even Republicans who disagree with her arguments, essentially approach education by the same means. While Clinton's book inspired many, it played a role in creating a preschool learning environment which only moved the needle of time value further away, from the limited time value everyone still held.
Children need new ways to be responsible long before they reach adulthood, and they need to be monetarily compensated for doing so. Even if they do not remain in the community of their childhood for a lifetime, they will have gained more meaningful friendships than otherwise would have been possible, by helping others. One of the best things about local investment is that it can be augmented by purposeful time choice. In knowledge use systems, these individuals will have already spent their younger years assisting their own classmates in their studies and ongoing work projects. What's more, access to local community investments from an early age, makes it possible to pursue other goals and challenges when one is ready to do so.
Human capital needs to remain closely associated with the income streams that individuals rely on, on a regular basis. The time value that friends still seek where possible, can become the compensated time value which local residents ultimately discover. As Dr. Madsen Pirie wrote recently, it is economic "nonsense" to assume that there needs to be a winner in every bargain. This holds particularly true for time arbitrage which holds both economic and social value. Investment capacity has been lost, because everyone has forgotten how time value actually exists in relation to resource value. As a result, the purpose of education has blurred considerably.
Just as private enterprise came to share responsibility for healthcare expenses in the U.S., public education relied on housing capital held by individuals (property taxation) to achieve its goals. One could say housing capital remains "parked" in local economies primarily for education expenses which outweigh those of other public service expenses. However, housing capital can be freed from providing educational income streams, so that people could be tapped directly for matched educational income streams. The direct link that once existed between human capital and educational potential, needs to be repaired.
Washington's subsidized support for housing, is the primary link national government now holds with local economies - large and small. Consequently this provides support for today's K-12 educational structures as well. Each Washington supported "bigger and better" house became bigger and better salaries for teachers in recent decades. Indeed, there was never an effective taxation system such as this for healthcare, in terms of local government budgets. As a result, local wealth didn't translate into local healthcare needs. This is one of the main reasons time value needs to become a serious option for healthcare needs, because many still can't afford healthcare in spite of its support from government and countless non profits.
Not only does human capital need to be more widely supported in community, housing as wealth needs to become a more flexible part of the equation. Stair step knowledge use could be a "pass it forward" learning method, by which students are compensated for passing on their core studies to the next younger group. This process would allow full utilization of human capital at every step of the process, in ways that generate much needed monetary flows in local economies.
In earlier societies, education often took place through an ongoing time use continuum. Not only does this natural process smooth consumption roles for multiple generations, it would also apply for a similar strategy in building component and land use investment. There is much potential wealth to be captured in the investment process of learning, which until now has been largely wasted in terms of personal identity and economic capacity. The incremental process of learning, pairs quite well with the incremental process of investment activity as one goes through life. By no means should these activities be reserved for only a small portion of humanity, when it is possible for anyone of limited means to grow a better future through a much needed, value in use economy.
Update - Nick Rowe has a good post today about human capital, as well:
http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/human-capital-and-land-capital.html
Thursday, February 12, 2015
Finance, Government, Monetarism: Some Assembly Required
...yet how to put it all together, given the fact these "pieces" scarcely coordinate at all in central banking settings? Even though these areas are vastly different, they remain the expected convergence for present day monetary policy. Truth be told, most among the public are more familiar with the ongoing gyrations of finance and government, than what is at stake in the monetary policies which affect their lives. As a result, market monetarism has more of an uphill climb for broad acceptance, than otherwise might be the case.
This issue has been on my mind since Richard Wagner and Vipin Veetil of George Mason University, dismissed NGDP targeting - basically on "general principle" - in a recent paper. In Bill Woolsey's response to their arguments, he noted that Richard Wagner was his finance professor decades earlier, which at least provides perspective for their rationale. Perhaps this also explains why Woolsey - as a "charter market monetarist member" - seemed nonplussed by their objections!
However, Wagner and Veetil's broad based attack on market monetarism, makes it difficult for some of us to counter their critique on specific terms. Indeed, it almost appears that their lack of confidence in market monetarism is due to a lack of confidence in the monetary role of central banking. For one thing: insisting that NGDP stabilization is a centralized dictate which does not consider microeconomic realities, misses the point. Of all the centralized activities a nation could assume, a nominal target is possibly the most benign of all. Unlike many centralized functions, this is one which seeks to represent all economic participants to the best degree possible.
Among other issues I already have with their assessment, recessions and depressions certainly do not cleanse, as Marcus Nunes also notes. Any lack of monetary stabilization only exacerbates already difficult circumstance in these cycles. In particular, monetary tightening which generates deflation is not helpful, as some Austrians assume. "Bad" deflation is not the result of normal price adjustments or productivity gain. Instead, shorting aggregate spending capacity means negative AD shocks which derail prior commitments on the part of numerous participants. The worst part about this situation is that resource potential is needlessly lost, and is not necessarily regained afterward.
In recent decades, financial and governmental interests have become more closely entwined. In the meantime, important monetary lessons from the Great Depression have been forgotten. One odd aspect of the financial perspective, is that it generates a political common ground among some who would otherwise be ideological opposites. Perhaps this alignment has bearing why the primary monetary interests of central banking appear as though lost in the shuffle. Who will tend to real monetary policy, if the Fed won't?
As Benjamin Cole indicated in a recent post, time aggregates also matter:
This issue has been on my mind since Richard Wagner and Vipin Veetil of George Mason University, dismissed NGDP targeting - basically on "general principle" - in a recent paper. In Bill Woolsey's response to their arguments, he noted that Richard Wagner was his finance professor decades earlier, which at least provides perspective for their rationale. Perhaps this also explains why Woolsey - as a "charter market monetarist member" - seemed nonplussed by their objections!
However, Wagner and Veetil's broad based attack on market monetarism, makes it difficult for some of us to counter their critique on specific terms. Indeed, it almost appears that their lack of confidence in market monetarism is due to a lack of confidence in the monetary role of central banking. For one thing: insisting that NGDP stabilization is a centralized dictate which does not consider microeconomic realities, misses the point. Of all the centralized activities a nation could assume, a nominal target is possibly the most benign of all. Unlike many centralized functions, this is one which seeks to represent all economic participants to the best degree possible.
Among other issues I already have with their assessment, recessions and depressions certainly do not cleanse, as Marcus Nunes also notes. Any lack of monetary stabilization only exacerbates already difficult circumstance in these cycles. In particular, monetary tightening which generates deflation is not helpful, as some Austrians assume. "Bad" deflation is not the result of normal price adjustments or productivity gain. Instead, shorting aggregate spending capacity means negative AD shocks which derail prior commitments on the part of numerous participants. The worst part about this situation is that resource potential is needlessly lost, and is not necessarily regained afterward.
In recent decades, financial and governmental interests have become more closely entwined. In the meantime, important monetary lessons from the Great Depression have been forgotten. One odd aspect of the financial perspective, is that it generates a political common ground among some who would otherwise be ideological opposites. Perhaps this alignment has bearing why the primary monetary interests of central banking appear as though lost in the shuffle. Who will tend to real monetary policy, if the Fed won't?
The unvarnished truth is that Americans are working the same amount of hours now as they did in 2009 - and also as in 1999.Whereas the labor force since 1999 has grown by 13 percent. However, these facts are being missed as the media portrays a "back to normal" economy. What monetary printing has been possible, was often disparaged - not just by the right, but many on the left who remain disappointed that more hasn't gone to fiscal activity. Is it possible to return to a central bank which is willing to stress to the public, the primacy of the monetary role? In a sense, the only thing a monetary offset even asks for, is that after financial institutions and governments get their representation, the public gains permission for their monetary representation as well.
Wednesday, February 11, 2015
Midweek Market Monetarist Links and Summaries - 2/11/15
"Long and variable lags" may well be a holdover from the late fifties. (Marcus Nunes) https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/05/sitting-in-confortable-perks/
The giant spotlight on the Fed might be worthwhile if there were actually something to illuminate...https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/05/fed-is-challenged-by-words/
The rise in employment still does not compare to the fall: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/06/january-had-the-highest-year-over-year-employment-gain-since-the-90s/
Some escape hatches are better than others: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/08/its-no-good-having-an-escape-hatch-if-you-act-stupid-once-youre-out/
There's politics involved in the "great" news: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/09/partisan-deceit/
Forward guidance hasn't worked out so well...https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/09/fed-version-of-jeopardy/
A "cleansing" recession...https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/10/mean-sobs/
A possibility of NGDP-linked bonds presents some unexpected clarity (Nick Rowe) http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/how-to-lie-with-ngdp-statistics.html
The policy instrument is subject to what is already laid out by the monetary target: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/instrument-independence-vs-target-independence-for-monetary-policy.html
At some point, shareholders would not "own" the assets... http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/money-as-closed-end-mutual-fund.html
Nick remembers the "great debt blog war of 2011/12." http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/debt-does-have-intergenerational-distributional-implications.html
Negative shocks tend to get more attention: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/fisher-calvo-ball-and-mankiw-skewed-bad-news-and-divine-coincidence-failures.html
Making food "travel back in time": http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/how-markets-convert-meat-into-vegetables.html
David Glasner's thoughts re a paper from Richard Lipsey: http://uneasymoney.com/2015/02/04/making-sense-of-the-phillips-curve/
Keynes understood the recovery from 40% deflation in the depression of 1920-21. http://uneasymoney.com/2015/02/05/a-keynesian-postscript-on-the-bright-and-shining-dearly-beloved-depression-of-1920-21/
In order of preference, some obvious options (Scott Sumner) : The lesser of evils and the art of compromise
The present fight is over both tactics and strategy: Charles Plosser on Fed discretion
Good news for Kuroda: Market Monetarism in Japan
A "sloppy" Bloomberg article: Noah Smith gets market monetarism wrong
"...if NGDP falls by 4%, consumption might fall by 2% while saving might fall by something like 10%." Think NGDI, not NGDP
Scott has a new paper at the Adam Smith Institute: http://www.adamsmith.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/therealproblemwasnominal1.pdf
His article for the Telegraph this week: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/comment/11399762/The-ECB-has-learnt-nothing-from-Japans-lost-decade.html
Scott at Econlog:
The new jobs figures and macro theory
Statist policies in China
Bill Woolsey has a chapter about NGDPLT and free banking in a new book: Renewing the Search for a Monetary Constitution
A response to Richard Wagner's Critique of Market Monetarism
Lars Christensen provides highlights from a paper Harada authored in 2010: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/09/kurodas-new-team-member-yutaka-harada/
"Fragile by Design" is quite a good book, but too fatalistic nonetheless: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/10/selgin-on-haber-and-calomiris/
An "over the top" headline - "It isn't deflation until we say so" (Bonnie Carr) https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/02/06/antics-from-the-grossly-overpaid-and-over-rated/
How much influence does the U.S. have? (Ravi Varghese) http://insecurityanalyst.blogspot.com/2015/02/monetary-orbit-do-we-have-kepler.html
Ben Southwood notes Scott Sumner's paper for ASI, and a related paper from the Harvard Kennedy School Nominal GDP targeting constituency on the rise
While the civilian labor force has grown by 13% since 1999...(Benjamin Cole) https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/11/the-hourless-recovery-er-recoveries/
The giant spotlight on the Fed might be worthwhile if there were actually something to illuminate...https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/05/fed-is-challenged-by-words/
The rise in employment still does not compare to the fall: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/06/january-had-the-highest-year-over-year-employment-gain-since-the-90s/
Some escape hatches are better than others: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/08/its-no-good-having-an-escape-hatch-if-you-act-stupid-once-youre-out/
There's politics involved in the "great" news: https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/09/partisan-deceit/
Forward guidance hasn't worked out so well...https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/09/fed-version-of-jeopardy/
A "cleansing" recession...https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/10/mean-sobs/
A possibility of NGDP-linked bonds presents some unexpected clarity (Nick Rowe) http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/how-to-lie-with-ngdp-statistics.html
The policy instrument is subject to what is already laid out by the monetary target: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/instrument-independence-vs-target-independence-for-monetary-policy.html
At some point, shareholders would not "own" the assets... http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/money-as-closed-end-mutual-fund.html
Nick remembers the "great debt blog war of 2011/12." http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/debt-does-have-intergenerational-distributional-implications.html
Negative shocks tend to get more attention: http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/fisher-calvo-ball-and-mankiw-skewed-bad-news-and-divine-coincidence-failures.html
Making food "travel back in time": http://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/2015/02/how-markets-convert-meat-into-vegetables.html
David Glasner's thoughts re a paper from Richard Lipsey: http://uneasymoney.com/2015/02/04/making-sense-of-the-phillips-curve/
Keynes understood the recovery from 40% deflation in the depression of 1920-21. http://uneasymoney.com/2015/02/05/a-keynesian-postscript-on-the-bright-and-shining-dearly-beloved-depression-of-1920-21/
In order of preference, some obvious options (Scott Sumner) : The lesser of evils and the art of compromise
The present fight is over both tactics and strategy: Charles Plosser on Fed discretion
Good news for Kuroda: Market Monetarism in Japan
A "sloppy" Bloomberg article: Noah Smith gets market monetarism wrong
"...if NGDP falls by 4%, consumption might fall by 2% while saving might fall by something like 10%." Think NGDI, not NGDP
Scott has a new paper at the Adam Smith Institute: http://www.adamsmith.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/therealproblemwasnominal1.pdf
His article for the Telegraph this week: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/comment/11399762/The-ECB-has-learnt-nothing-from-Japans-lost-decade.html
Scott at Econlog:
The new jobs figures and macro theory
Statist policies in China
Bill Woolsey has a chapter about NGDPLT and free banking in a new book: Renewing the Search for a Monetary Constitution
A response to Richard Wagner's Critique of Market Monetarism
Lars Christensen provides highlights from a paper Harada authored in 2010: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/09/kurodas-new-team-member-yutaka-harada/
"Fragile by Design" is quite a good book, but too fatalistic nonetheless: http://marketmonetarist.com/2015/02/10/selgin-on-haber-and-calomiris/
An "over the top" headline - "It isn't deflation until we say so" (Bonnie Carr) https://dajeeps.wordpress.com/2015/02/06/antics-from-the-grossly-overpaid-and-over-rated/
How much influence does the U.S. have? (Ravi Varghese) http://insecurityanalyst.blogspot.com/2015/02/monetary-orbit-do-we-have-kepler.html
Ben Southwood notes Scott Sumner's paper for ASI, and a related paper from the Harvard Kennedy School Nominal GDP targeting constituency on the rise
While the civilian labor force has grown by 13% since 1999...(Benjamin Cole) https://thefaintofheart.wordpress.com/2015/02/11/the-hourless-recovery-er-recoveries/
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)