Why does the form of deflation we call "good" (since it translates into more affordable product and more output), not function as the same clear positive, for the economic value of human capital as time based product? After all, if the cost of high skill services could be gradually reduced and made more widely available, much as tradable goods have become, "small" wages would hold more real economic value. Likewise, smaller aggregate wage levels would gradually allow the productive agglomeration costs of real estate to be modified in many areas as well.
There's a problem however, for good deflation in terms of time based service product. Alas: What tends towards cumulative inflation rather than good deflation, is how many individuals meet their ongoing expenses and asset costs as those costs currently exist. Unlike forms of product separate from time (which of course aren't human), time based product costs are attached to our human responsibilities to pay bills on an ongoing basis. While we are appreciative if we can access someone else's time, good deflation for time product may nonetheless feel like the bad deflation which impacts labour value during depressions, if that time value happens to be our own.
Our time is also scarce in relation to most goods. Consequently, in order to meet the human capital costs others posses, many seek to raise their own time value. This sets up a chain reaction, whereby others still need to increase the value of their time, so as to access important forms of time based product. This extensive internal inflation process runs exactly counter, to the good deflation which tradable sector activity has contributed to prosperity in recent centuries.
All this holds, regardless of one's monetary compensation for their time units in the form of labour or skills arbitrage. It certainly matters for the time arbitrage I've suggested as an alternative, which would need to be crafted so as to directly address the internal inflation problem. That's why it would be necessary to define new organizational settings for services, learning patterns, infrastructure, housing and other building components so as to make good deflation for time value a reasonable possibility.
Consider how infrastructure and real estate costs have proven relatively amenable to good deflation in tradable sectors. While limited aspects of tradable sector activity needs locations in areas with high real estate costs, much tradable sector production has far more flexibility and mobility. However, in order to accomplish this, many aspects of organizational capacity are integrated into single sustainable settings which have at least a relative degree of independence from place and geography.
Conversely, too many aspects of high skill services have been excessively place dependent for productive agglomeration, which only contributes to the difficulty of achieving good deflation in non tradable sectors. This coordination problem helps to explain why the high skill work of our most prosperous areas is no longer a simple matching process in terms of employment, given the relative few who now manage wealth in lieu of others. Since non tradable sector high skill knowledge does not scale as does tradable sector activity, it needs a horizontal organizational approach which encourages greater marketplace capacity and productive agglomeration which goes well beyond our most prosperous areas.
A new institution is needed which could place productive agglomeration for non tradable sector knowledge use into a combined organizational framework. In these defined equilibrium settings, individuals would not suffer the extreme losses in purchasing power, that would otherwise accompany good deflation in time based services in a completely open equilibrium. Of course, open equilibrium would still apply for tradable sector activitiy, since most individuals can still access and contribute to the good deflation of tradable sectors. However, the closed non tradable sector equilibrium would make it realistic to pursue good deflation as an important time based services goal.
Valuable though good deflation would be for time based product, there are other reasons to utilize symmetrical time value as a mass produced services commodity. Time arbitrage would allow time based product to function as a basic human capital building block, instead of simply another societal cost which places uncertain demands on the earth's resource capacity. One of the main problems of inflationary time value, is the fact there is no time based services steady state to rely upon, when time value exists solely in a dependent relationship with earth's other resource capacity. By bringing good deflation to time value, we could create a steady state for applied knowledge which allows us to more precisely determine the productivity of our own efforts, in relation to the productivity relationships of our other institutions.
No comments:
Post a Comment